Rate "Magic" and post your review/comments (New Poll - Magic music vid)

IneedYou23

Up With The Birds
Coldplayer
Joined
Apr 5, 2004
Messages
1,101
I gave it a 7. I love how the song gives off this chill vibe. On first listen it sort of reminded me of a Red Hot Chili Peppers song, I'm not sure why but thats what my initial thought was. I don't mind the electronic drums all that much. I think it gives the song an identity. While the electronic drums are prominent in the song, they aren't played through out the whole song. On the second verse the snare sound changes for a bit. Then at about 2:33 the electronic snare changes to a traditional snare drum sound. I think it gives that part of the song a little more punch and works well. They did that with Atlas too. Jonnys guitar at 3:15 sounds something the Edge would play. I think this song has a lot of different elements in it. It's not their best, but it's not bad. There is something about the song that just works for me. The way Chris voice sounds and sings, or Guy's bass. It works for me.
 

Florian

New Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 7, 2013
Messages
152
I've been seeing a lot of reviews on here saying " why would Chris write this it sounds like a middle schooler wrote it" and many things similar to that but what if it wasn't Chris that wrote it? :confused:
 

mayrn43

Up&Up
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 4, 2014
Messages
1,658
I've been seeing a lot of reviews on here saying " why would Chris write this it sounds like a middle schooler wrote it" and many things similar to that but what if it wasn't Chris that wrote it? :confused:
I doubt it


Sent from my iPod touch using Tapatalk
 

MosesTheMarshmallow

You're a Sky Full of Stars
Coldplayer
Joined
Nov 19, 2010
Messages
1,368
I gave it a 7. I love how the song gives off this chill vibe. On first listen it sort of reminded me of a Red Hot Chili Peppers song, I'm not sure why but thats what my initial thought was. I don't mind the electronic drums all that much. I think it gives the song an identity. While the electronic drums are prominent in the song, they aren't played through out the whole song. On the second verse the snare sound changes for a bit. Then at about 2:33 the electronic snare changes to a traditional snare drum sound. I think it gives that part of the song a little more punch and works well. They did that with Atlas too. Jonnys guitar at 3:15 sounds something the Edge would play. I think this song has a lot of different elements in it. It's not their best, but it's not bad. There is something about the song that just works for me. The way Chris voice sounds and sings, or Guy's bass. It works for me.
Indeed. A friend thought it was RHCP in the first 5 seconds too. The bass tone is very similar to Otherside. And the actual chord progression is a little like Scar Tissue.

Everything else about this assessment I agree with too - nice electronic and notelectronic balance. Is good and catchy...but could have been a little bigger and better in places.
 

kcp

Livin' life in Technicolor
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 7, 2014
Messages
315
Not sure how so many people are down on the lyrics !! How can you not like lyrics , that state love is magic !! Love IS magic and it's simplicity is quite possibly the greatest thing in the world .. I love the understated song ! I do agree a lot of other songs have been more poetic / deep not so straight forward but this is to the point and needs no antics ... Love it :) can't wait to see what else is to come !! That's my two cents worth lol
 

Jedi Leo

A guy full of stars
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
4,864
Mostly because they are too simple and repetitive.
Yeah I can totally see why people would find the lyrics subpar, but after all they do go very well with the minimalistic music. They are a good fit in my opinion. We know Chris is capable of writing intricate lyrics (Atlas, Violet Hill, etc,), so this was definitely a conscious decision on their part, to keep it simple and direct. :)
 

OnlookerDelay

New Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 9, 2008
Messages
109
I gave it a "5", because it pretty much leaves me unaffected. I'm not a fan of overproduced, electronic drums, and overly used synths. The guys in Coldplay are great musicians; I want to hear what they can play naturally. I'm hearing less and less of that in their music as they age. I think this is why I prefer the live versions of every song from MX over the studio versions; they're more natural. I could have probably gone 6, or possibly 7 on Magic if the lyrics didn't sound like they were written by a middle schooler. Chris is usually a lot stronger lyrically and I'm surprised these lyrics passed Will's inspection :stunned:
 

42JTR

Watching my life on the skyline
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
2,245
I gave it an 8 because to me it sounds like the real Coldplay again and shows that the ''old Coldplay'' are still in there . And I'm liking it even more now. It's such a happy and relaxing song.
 

LARD

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 12, 2005
Messages
326
I believe that 'Magic' is not quite dead-on what they should be doing: it's very 'clean' sounding, production-wise, and the lyrics are a little too simplistic. However, I think that this new more relaxed and understated sound generally bodes well for the upcoming album, which is bound to contain some interesting tracks.

Coldplay have a history of releasing a leading single that is designed to be a 'taster' for the sound of the new album... but it's usually not the best track from it. Hopefully this is the case again!
 

Jedi Leo

A guy full of stars
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
4,864
Coldplay have a history of releasing a leading single that is designed to be a 'taster' for the sound of the new album... but it's usually not the best track from it. Hopefully this is the case again!
Exactly. Their first single is never the best track of the album, but like you said a taster. I am sure Magic follows along those lines. I personally can´t wait to hear them at the iTunes Festival. If they do like they did with MX, we will probably hear more new tracks! :laugh3:
 

EC-JTR

Livin' life in Technicolor
Coldplayer
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
244
For me only 8. The sound in the start of the song is "dry". No background. The middle to the end is better...just a personal fan opinión... :)
 

gus

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 31, 2007
Messages
502
honestly i think is a 10 because the lyrics and the melodies fit together in a good way the lyrics maybe lack of advanced poetry but this song i think, it was meant to be the first single so maybe its the more easy to listen song in the album
 
Last edited:

gjohnson

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 5, 2011
Messages
223
I changed my vote from a 9 to a 10 on the poll. Granted, the lyrics on their songs have not been as great as on pre MX albums -- my fav: "When your life is architectured by a carnival of idiots on show you better lie low" -- but the more you listen, the more you pick up the complexity of the production. It's also more accessible to the general music-listening population than Midnight, if you know what I mean. I am hoping this album grows even better with each new single that is released.
 

DiOli05

Mrs. Berryman
Coldplayer
Joined
Sep 29, 2011
Messages
2,636
I loved it from the first 3 seconds. It made me smile instantly, and by the end of it i was crying happy tears becuase of how sweet it is.
I am sure they can do best than this, which is why i gave it an 8. The song is lovely, the lyrics are kind of simple though, but why make a love song complicated, right? idk. i get mixed feelings i guess.
I want everyone to hear it, but please do not pay much attention to it is what goes through my mind.
 

MidnightSpies

Livin' life in Technicolor
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 7, 2011
Messages
312
Nice and sweet but so so simple. I like the quiet start of the song, but the 'and I dont and I don't' reminds me of music I've heard before. It's so safe and not creative to me, and even a bit boring and I like boring! I looove all the Coldplay songs that some would call boring. I like simplicity, but this is just too much of an easy catchy pop track. The song stayed in my head after only the first listen.
As soon as I here the guitar I feel it becomes something more, and more Coldplay, but still..
It's not exactly a song I will keep listening to for years. I hope the rest is more creative and interesting like Midnight. Not that the whole album should sound like Midnight, but just some more originality/creativity, I miss that in Magic.
Lyrics same story.. does Chris want his lyrics to be criticized even more? I dont understand that..
 
Top