Welcome to Coldplaying!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!

X&Y vs Ghost Stories

thetelephoneline

Flying Dutchman
Coldplayer
Joined
Oct 25, 2010
Messages
1,524
Again, you all know it! :lol:

I included the target bonus tracks to give Ghost Stories a little more tracks to compare with X&Y

edit: i changed some things now because All Your Friends was there twice and Till Kingdome Come was missing and Atlas is also included now.

Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]
 

rafaelchampion

Stare at me.
Coldplayer
Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
2,452
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head
Round two: What if vs True Love
Round three: White Shadows vs Ink
Round four: Fix You vs Magic
Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars
Round six: X&Y vs Midnight
Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms
Round eight: A Message vs Oceans
Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends
Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story
Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O
Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs All Your Friends - Again?
 

lukaz42

New Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Messages
11
Round One: Square One
Round Two: True Love
Round Three: Ink
Round Four: Fix You
Round Five: Talk
Round Six: Midnight
Round Seven: Speed Of Sound
Round Eight: Oceans
Round Nine: Low
Round Ten: A Message
Round Eleven: O
Round Twelve: All your Friends
 

Written In Graffiti

Missing The Mark
Coldplayer
Joined
Feb 24, 2012
Messages
200
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelve: Twisted Logic vs All Your Friends

6:6.
 

jc90

A Herp Full Of Derp
Honorary Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Aug 29, 2005
Messages
5,974
Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs All Your Friends
All Your Friends x2 and no 'Til Kingdom Come? c'mon now. maybe throw in Atlas to balance? iunno
 

mayrn43

Up&Up
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 4, 2014
Messages
1,658
Round one: Square One

Round two: What if

Round three: White Shadows

Round four: Fix You

Round five: A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound

Round eight: Oceans

Round nine: All Your Friends

Round ten: Ghost Story

Round eleven: O

Round twelve: Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come

X&Y: 6
Ghost Stories + Atlas: 7
 

the_escapist

Just a flock of birds
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 19, 2006
Messages
5,317
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head
Round two: What if vs True Love
Round three: White Shadows vs Ink
Round four: Fix You vs Magic
Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars
Round six: X&Y vs Midnight
Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms
Round eight: A Message vs Oceans
Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends
Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story
Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O
Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas
Round thirteen: Till Kingdom Come vs O [part two/reprise]

X&Y: 6
GS: 7

And for the first time in this type of battles, Ghost Stories wins!
 

Ultravioletlight25

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
May 3, 2008
Messages
490
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

X&Y = 12
GS = 1

Winner X&Y
 

42JTR

Watching my life on the skyline
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
2,207
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS! :p

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

GS:7
X&Y:6

Close call but a win for GS :)
 

42JTR

Watching my life on the skyline
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
2,207
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

X&Y = 12
GS = 1

Winner X&Y
I have this feeling you really like X&Y? :p
 

lennyrott2

New Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 6, 2014
Messages
147
1 Square One vs Always In My Head (really hard pick)

2.What If vs True Love

3.White Shadows vs Ink

4.Fix You vs Magic

5.Talk vs ASFOS

6.X&Y vs Midnight

7.Speed Of Sound vs Anohter's Arms

8. A Message vs Oceans

9. Low vs All Your Friends

10.A Message vs Ghost Story

11. Swallowed By The Sea vs O

12. Twisted Logic vs Atlas

13. Til Kingdom Come vs O (Reprise)

X&Y--10 Ghost Stories---3
 

KatePT

Cartoon Heart
Coldplayer
Joined
Apr 3, 2014
Messages
290
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic (can't choose) XD

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

GS: 6 X&Y:5
 

Troyani

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Apr 28, 2014
Messages
46
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink (That was hard)

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: The Hardest Part vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

X&Y: 11 GS (Target Edition + Atlas): 2
 
Top