Welcome to Coldplaying!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!

X&Y vs Ghost Stories

Politikian

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Apr 24, 2014
Messages
188
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans (really hard)

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: The Hardest Part vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O (really hard)

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Til Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

GS+Atlas: 7
X&Y: 6
 

HowCouldIForget

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
236
You don't have the Ghost Stories tracklist in the right order so doing my own

Square One vs Always in My Head

What If vs Magic

White Shadows vs True Love

Fix You vs Ink

Talk vs Midnight

X&Y vs Another's Arms

Speed of Sound vs Oceans

A Message vs A Sky Full of Stars

Low vs O

The Hardest Part vs All Your Friends

Swallowed in the Sea vs Ghost Story

Twisted Logic vs O (Reprise)


8-4
 

roquejose

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Sep 6, 2008
Messages
339
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]
 

Jdckcom

Cold and Vicious
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 1, 2011
Messages
37
Round 1: Square One
Round 2: True Love
Round 3: White Shadows
Round 4: Fix You
Round 5: Talk
Round 6: X&Y
Round 7: Speed Of Sound
Round 8: Oceans
Round 9: Low
Round 10: A Message
Round 11: O
Round 12: Atlas
Round 13: 'Till Kingdom Come

X&Y: 9
Ghost Stories Target Edition + Atlas: 4
 

WeddingDom

Such a heavenly view
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 18, 2010
Messages
1,355
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: The Hardest Part vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

X&Y: 9
Ghost Stories: 4
 

gus

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 31, 2007
Messages
502
Round one: Always In My Head
Round two: True Love
Round three: Ink
Round four: FixYou
Round five: A Sky Full Of Stars
Round six: Midnight
Round seven: Another's Arms
Round eight: A message
Round nine: Low
Round ten: Ghost Story
Round eleven: O
Round twelf: Atlas
Round thirteen: Til kingdom come

I think its unfair to compare extra songs with the songs that were part of an album.
GS+atlas: 9 X&y: 4 there is no way to x&y be better than GS.... at least for me.
 

Cold003

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Jul 30, 2012
Messages
61
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head (hard choise)

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: The Hardest Part vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come

X&Y: 7
GS: 5

its unfair to compare Till Kingdome Come with O [part two/reprise] so i will not count it
 

Badger44

New Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 25, 2014
Messages
7
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms Really Tough!

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

7-6 Ghost Stories Wow! Some of those were really hard.
 

ciaA26

Stood on the Edge
Coldplayer
Joined
Jul 29, 2013
Messages
112
Round one: Square One

Round two: What if

Round three: White Shadows

Round four: Fix You

Round five: Talk

Round six: Midnight

Round seven:Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message

Round nine: All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O (I genuinely can't choose)

Round twelf: Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come
 

HowCouldIForget

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
236
Rd 1: Square One vs Always in My Head

Rd 2: What If vs Magic

Rd 3: White Shadows vs Ink

Rd 4: Fix You vs True Love

Rd 5: Talk vs Midnight

Rd 6: X&Y vs Another's Arms

Rd 7: speed of Sound vs Oceans

Rd 8: A Message vs A Sky Full of Stars

Rd 9: Low vs O

Rd 10: The Hardest Part vs All Your Friends

Rd 11: Swallowed in the Sea vs All Your Friends

Rd 12: Twisted Logic vs Ghost Story + O (Reprise)

Rd 13: Til Kingdom Come vs Ghost Stories + O (Reprise)

X&Y- 10
Ghost Stories- 3

Neva had a chance bro :rolleyes:
 

Sparky

Turn Your Magic On
Honorary Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 23, 2008
Messages
4,881
Round one: Square One vs

Round two: vs True Love - This was the hardest decision ever, True Love edges it over What If, just about, both in my top 5 CP songs.

Round three: White Shadows vs

Round four: Fix You vs

Round five: Talk vs

Round six: X&Y vs

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs

Round eight: A Message vs

Round nine: Low vs

Round ten: vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: vs O

Round twelf: vs Atlas

Round thirteen: vs O [part two/reprise]

That's 8 X&Y - 6 Ghost Stories I think, some odd pairings there! X&Y is my fav album anyway, given time, Ghost Stories might overtake
 

FlockOfBirds

New Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
May 15, 2014
Messages
11
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink (TIE. Both songs are amazing)

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

GS: 6 X&Y: 6
 

Eskapist

Livin' life in Technicolor
Coldplayer
Joined
Apr 26, 2013
Messages
133
Rd 1: Square One vs Always in My Head

Rd 2: What If vs Magic

Rd 3: White Shadows vs Ink

Rd 4: Fix You vs True Love

Rd 5: Talk vs Midnight

Rd 6: X&Y vs Another's Arms

Rd 7: speed of Sound vs Oceans

Rd 8: A Message vs A Sky Full of Stars

Rd 9: Low vs O

Rd 10: The Hardest Part vs All Your Friends

Rd 11: Swallowed in the Sea vs All Your Friends

Rd 12: Twisted Logic vs Ghost Story + O (Reprise)

Rd 13: Til Kingdom Come vs Ghost Stories + O (Reprise)

GS : 5
XY : 8
 

hente44

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Dec 20, 2010
Messages
401
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What if vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]
 

wheresmypenis

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 2, 2014
Messages
188
all goes for X&Y except the song Xand Y on the album(its awfull) and O does it for me better so only one winner here in GS X&Y is the best album eva
 

HurtsLikeHeaven42

Leave A Light on
Coldplayer
Joined
Jun 15, 2013
Messages
1,156
Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

Round two: What If vs True Love

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

Round seven: Speed of Sound vs Another's Arms

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

Round thirteen: Till Kingdom Come vs O [part two/reprise]

X&Y 5 GS 8

GS Wins!
 
Top