Jump to content
🛒 SHOP THE NEW CHRISTMAS LIGHTS COLLECTION 🛒
thetelephoneline

X&Y vs Ghost Stories

Recommended Posts

Round one: Always In My Head

Round two: True Love

Round three: Ink

Round four: FixYou

Round five: A Sky Full Of Stars

Round six: Midnight

Round seven: Another's Arms

Round eight: A message

Round nine: Low

Round ten: Ghost Story

Round eleven: O

Round twelf: Atlas

Round thirteen: Til kingdom come

 

I think its unfair to compare extra songs with the songs that were part of an album.

GS+atlas: 9 X&y: 4 there is no way to x&y be better than GS.... at least for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head (hard choise)

 

Round two: What if vs True Love

 

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

 

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

 

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

 

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

 

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

 

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

 

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

 

Round ten: The Hardest Part vs Ghost Story

 

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

 

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

 

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come

 

X&Y: 7

GS: 5

 

its unfair to compare Till Kingdome Come with O [part two/reprise] so i will not count it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

 

Round two: What if vs True Love

 

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

 

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

 

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

 

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms Really Tough!

 

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

 

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

 

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

 

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

 

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

 

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

 

7-6 Ghost Stories Wow! Some of those were really hard.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Round one: Square One

 

Round two: What if

 

Round three: White Shadows

 

Round four: Fix You

 

Round five: Talk

 

Round six: Midnight

 

Round seven:Another's Arms

 

Round eight: A Message

 

Round nine: All Your Friends

 

Round ten: A Message

 

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O (I genuinely can't choose)

 

Round twelf: Atlas

 

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rd 1: Square One vs Always in My Head

 

Rd 2: What If vs Magic

 

Rd 3: White Shadows vs Ink

 

Rd 4: Fix You vs True Love

 

Rd 5: Talk vs Midnight

 

Rd 6: X&Y vs Another's Arms

 

Rd 7: speed of Sound vs Oceans

 

Rd 8: A Message vs A Sky Full of Stars

 

Rd 9: Low vs O

 

Rd 10: The Hardest Part vs All Your Friends

 

Rd 11: Swallowed in the Sea vs All Your Friends

 

Rd 12: Twisted Logic vs Ghost Story + O (Reprise)

 

Rd 13: Til Kingdom Come vs Ghost Stories + O (Reprise)

 

X&Y- 10

Ghost Stories- 3

 

Neva had a chance bro :rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Round one: Square One vs

 

Round two: vs True Love - This was the hardest decision ever, True Love edges it over What If, just about, both in my top 5 CP songs.

 

Round three: White Shadows vs

 

Round four: Fix You vs

 

Round five: Talk vs

 

Round six: X&Y vs

 

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs

 

Round eight: A Message vs

 

Round nine: Low vs

 

Round ten: vs Ghost Story

 

Round eleven: vs O

 

Round twelf: vs Atlas

 

Round thirteen: vs O [part two/reprise]

 

That's 8 X&Y - 6 Ghost Stories I think, some odd pairings there! X&Y is my fav album anyway, given time, Ghost Stories might overtake

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

 

Round two: What if vs True Love

 

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink (TIE. Both songs are amazing)

 

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

 

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

 

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

 

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

 

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

 

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

 

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

 

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

 

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

 

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

 

GS: 6 X&Y: 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rd 1: Square One vs Always in My Head

 

Rd 2: What If vs Magic

 

Rd 3: White Shadows vs Ink

 

Rd 4: Fix You vs True Love

 

Rd 5: Talk vs Midnight

 

Rd 6: X&Y vs Another's Arms

 

Rd 7: speed of Sound vs Oceans

 

Rd 8: A Message vs A Sky Full of Stars

 

Rd 9: Low vs O

 

Rd 10: The Hardest Part vs All Your Friends

 

Rd 11: Swallowed in the Sea vs All Your Friends

 

Rd 12: Twisted Logic vs Ghost Story + O (Reprise)

 

Rd 13: Til Kingdom Come vs Ghost Stories + O (Reprise)

 

GS : 5

XY : 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

 

Round two: What if vs True Love

 

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

 

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

 

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

 

Round seven: Speed Of Sound vs Another's Arms

 

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

 

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

 

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

 

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

 

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

 

Round thirteen: Till Kingdome Come vs O [part two/reprise]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

all goes for X&Y except the song Xand Y on the album(its awfull) and O does it for me better so only one winner here in GS X&Y is the best album eva

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Round one: Square One vs Always In My Head

 

Round two: What If vs True Love

 

Round three: White Shadows vs Ink

 

Round four: Fix You vs Magic

 

Round five: Talk vs A Sky Full Of Stars

 

Round six: X&Y vs Midnight

 

Round seven: Speed of Sound vs Another's Arms

 

Round eight: A Message vs Oceans

 

Round nine: Low vs All Your Friends

 

Round ten: A Message vs Ghost Story

 

Round eleven: Swallowed In The Sea vs O

 

Round twelf: Twisted Logic vs Atlas

 

Round thirteen: Till Kingdom Come vs O [part two/reprise]

 

X&Y 5 GS 8

 

GS Wins!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...