There have been a lot of discussions coming up in the U2 fan community about Coldplay. A lot of us are big fans of Coldplay. And since U2 is in the studio at the moment, and I guess Coldplay is doing a good job of filling the void...with Chris filling that enormous Bono-shaped hole, lol.
Anyway, there has been some discussion comparing Coldplay to U2...You know, since there has been a lot of talk in the media and on the Internet of Coldplay being the "next U2." It just keeps coming up. You almost can't come across an interview or review of Coldplay without seeing/hearing the name U2 come up. My feeling on this is...It is simply too early in Coldplay's career to compare. That goes without saying that Coldplay is very different from U2 anyway.
So then why are people comparing them?
Perhaps you guys have your own theories on this, but -- aside from the fact that, interestingly, both bands are huge Radiohead fans and cite them as one of the biggest influences on the music they are making at the moment -- it seems to me that it isn't so much about the way the music sounds, as it is about the feelings that Coldplay's music evokes. And also the social consciousness that they seem to possess, which they have very much in common with U2. And, whether directly or indirectly, this social consciousness manifests itself in the music. Maybe it's a technical thing, like the keys that the songs are played in, or the tempo...Or maybe it's that other little thing that both lead singers/lyricists seem to have in common -- a belief in God. Or maybe it IS God; I don't know.
Anyway, there have been a few reviews of Coldplay's recent shows that complain of the band not "connecting" with the audience well enough. I've listened to a few recent boots, and while in some shows they seem to connect with the audience more than in others, I find it hard to believe that this is THE one major complaint throughout. Consider this conversation I had recently with a friend of mine. She does not like Coldplay at all, but we both like U2:
HER: In the last week, all of a sudden there've been articles
saying Coldplay lacks spark, emotional depth.
ME: well they're full of shit
HER: No, they weren't. They explained it really well, why they thought it was that way.
ME: Not the ones I've read.
HER: Hang on a bloody god damned second and I'll get you a #!%ing review. (Sorry she had a mouth on her today lol.)
HER: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/atu2/message/4690
HER: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/atu2/message/4714
ME: shit i got chocolate on my mouse
ME: ok a.) i'm not a member of atu2
ME: and b.) i don't care what the reviewers have to say
ME: If u2 got shite reviews would you still love them?
HER: Yes
ME: well there you go
HER: But Coldplay is still very one-tempo.
ME: well then i guess it happens to be a tempo i like
ME: but ya know
ME: i think we're a little spoiled by u2
ME: affa (saw Coldplay at the Hollywood Bowl, said they were AMAZING) said the only complaint that she had about coldplay was that they don't connect with their audience like u2 does
HER: And that's the complaint in those two articles.
ME: And I was like, well most bands *don't*. U2 is very special
HER: And a band *should* connect.
ME: but I think the reason people are complaining about it in coldplay's case is because their music makes you want that connection.
HER: *Would bet money that Metallica, REM and all those guys connect with the audience*
ME: well not always...i mean sometimes it's enough just to be good, or to crack funny jokes in between songs
ME: well coldplay is still a very young band too
ME: at least in america
HER: *Bets U2 was already making the connection*
HER: when they were "still a very young band".
ME: don't compare them to u2
ME: u2 is #&%ing amazing
HER: Why not?
HER: Everyone else is.
ME: you said yourself it annoys you
ME: and i really don't think it's worth comparing
HER: It annoys me that peole say they're *as good as* U2.
ME: well it depends on what you mean by good
ME: it's all very opinion-based, andrea
ME: the general consensus in the world is that the beatles are the best band ever
ME: but i know people who don't even like the beatles
Now, I have yet to see Coldplay in concert, so I really can't provide my own insight, but I am really interested in hearing from those of you who have seen them in concert. I'll post a poll, but I'd like you guys to elaborate, and at least say when the concert you saw was.
I know I talked about U2 here, but it is only because these discussions I've been having happen to be in the U2 community. But I don't intend this to be a Coldplay vs. U2 thread...because I think a thread like that would go nowhere fast, lol. I love both bands. ::shrugs:: And music is not a competition anyway; usually it is very much the opposite.
What I am really interested in is how Coldplay makes you feel. I get the sense that they've got something special about them, and I rarely feel that way about a band.
dot.