maybe its just me but in my opinion the original version of "talk" makes much more sense lyrically, then again i could just be upset cuz they cut out my favorite part of the song but i was just curious if other people felt the same way...and let me just state that i still like the new version of "talk" but thats all i got to say...for now :)

I like the old version better.

 

Hasn't this been discussed over and over again/

Does it have to make sense? I didn't overlisten to the first version, and i like the new one more YAY :D

Hasn't this been discussed over and over again/

Yes it has!

Oh look what I found, another thread on this topic! :idea2:

 

http://www.coldplaying.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=17470&start=0

Most of the threads now are just recycles of another... :/ I like the new talk better, for the record. Despite overlistening the old one.

i'm not asking which one is better, im asking if other people feel that the older version makes more sense lyrically, and as far as i have seen on this board (and i could be mistaken) this hasnt really been discussed, the only thing that has been discussed so far is what you are doing and that is picking what one you like more

:stunned: It's the same thing!!!

well, i don't think it makes more sense, but at the same time i don't think it has to make more sense, it's a song, a poem of sorts not a traditional story, the emotions are the same he's just expressing it in a slightly more abstract way

:stunned: It's the same thing!!!

 

no its not cuz i never said i liked it more than the new version, i was just giving my opinion but of course just like on every message board people have to go and confuse things and turn the thread into something totally different than the starting topic...and thank you lumberjack for at least staying on topic and you are right it doesnt HAVE to make sense cuz it is a poem/song but still maybe it just sounds kinda weird to me after listening to the older version so much

Not the same thing, but couldn't gone on one of the other topics :) But it's ok.

 

Lyrically I think they both make sense...why doesn't the new one make sense to you?

Oh look what I found, another thread on this topic! :idea2:

 

http://www.coldplaying.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=17470&start=0

 

damn justine can anythin escape ur eye? :lol: :lol:

I like the new version... the old one lacked a certain something... I dont know what it is exactly.... but it lacked.