Which one do you like better?

 

i personally think X is put together better, the tracks seem to fit together, as for Y, i wouldn't have put twisted logic last, i might have put proof in in it's place and moved logic in the place of swallowed in the sea and then made swallowed in the sea a b-side...

 

+ is quite good, but it's only one song, so i won't vote for it myself.

This thread was already done before. But anyway, I like X better, because it doesn't have Swallowed In The Sea in it.

http://forum.coldplaying.com/viewtopic.php?t=18037

I voted + since it's too hard to choose! :stunned:

 

Y has Speed of Sound... :sneaky: which I really don't like

and

X has the new version of Talk. :sneaky:

 

With the old version of Talk I think X would have made the perfect record. But it has the new one so they are still stuck neck and neck...and people do say 'Proof' should have been on the Y record, but I still need to hear it so I'll comment on that later...

Y, shame it has Swallowed in the sea and doesn't have X&Y on it.

i like a mix if both but if i had to choose it would be X

Both. There's Swallowed in the sea and The hardest part on the Y side but there's Low and A messeage which ones I really like so it was hard to choose.

Why no love for Swallowed in the Sea? I just put X because I like all but Talk. I don't much like Speed of Sound or Low as much as the others on Y.

No love for swallowed cuz it's a terrible song.

Nah....

 

I like them both :blush:

FAvourite songs from the new one are Low and Till Kingdom Come, so Y. Also, Y doesn't seem to be 'trying' as hard to be good, which makes it better (that make sense?) in my opinion.

ît makes sense.

;)

i picked Y only becaue of Swallowed in the Sea. and well, A message too and the Hardest Part

 

but what if and fix are missing

and i hate twisted logic

I think X-side is better, because Square One and Fix You are in it. :)

i think teh all album is just good.i cant imagine another songs on it

I started off liking X but it shifted to Y. All the Y songs are so good!

I must say that ive listened to Y more and thats probably why i like it more but i mean x is also very good.... :)

undefined :D

I choose the Y one, because i think Y is an symbol of man, and I'm a man!

X is the best. I love all the songs on that side. I love loads from the other side to. But I am sticking to X.

http://forum.coldplaying.com/viewtopic.php?t=18037

 

 

we all love'em.. but come on!!! :P