I know that at least here in America, there are going to be some pissed off fans when they first hear X&Y. The fact is, many here got really into Coldplay after Yellow and especially after The Scientist, which was played virtually on the minute here, so I really feel that people (specifically female fans) looking for those intimate piano ballads will initially be very disappointed with this album.
That being said….
I really like the new music, but not necessarily the studio album. I first heard songs like “Low” and “Fix You” at the Boston Avalon buzz gig, and I thought they were amazing. When I first heard the leak of the album, though, the studio versions of the songs did not strike me at all as the live versions did. It took me a lot (a lot) of listens to really start loving X&Y (which I do now) but that was the exact same way for me with AROBTTH and Parachutes. Coldplay music NEEDS to be absorbed, and I’m afraid that for many of those fans looking for another Scientist, another instant gratifier, the fans who believe the only songs worth listening to on AROBTTH are The Scientist, Clocks, and In My Place, they will lack the patience to let this album sink in.
However, the Twisted Logic Tour is the best thing that Coldplay will do for itself to win back a fan base that they may alienate with X&Y. They have virtually sold out all venues, so this will be the tour of the summer. When fans hear songs like “Fix You” and “A Message” live, the intimacy that I believe is missing, hidden behind the synths on the studio album, will be restored. Please, if you are an avid Coldplay fan and are disappointed with X&Y, don’t be. If you are lucky enough to have tickets to one of their shows, you won’t be disappointed. In fact, you will appreciate the songs even more.