people seemed to hear a small similarity between coldplay's 'the scientist' and sum 41's 'pieces'.

 

here

 

listen to this for the mashup.

wasn't there a thread wiff that link recently?

ooops. looks like i broke the golden rule of do not re-post info. sorry y'all. i know this kind of thing is frustrating.

I like this :) :P

Is it the exact same chords? Or is the "sum 41 guitars" changed to fit "The Scientist"? :huh:

haha. I Guess they do sound similar in terms of chords, and some certain choice of notes.

Just shows what you can do with pretty much the same notes and chords, in making a great song, and a fairly average, typical american Trash, song. Unlucky Sum41

Canadian :P

I like it... and I realize that there are 2 other sum 42 songs that I like... :embarrased: does that make me a bad person.. :embarrased:

I like it too, not as good as the mix with Colplday and radiohead featuring the scientist tho. :wink3:

Anyone else know of any other Coldplay Vs. X songs?

Not too bad :)

to be honest.. at the beginning it sounded good but torwards the verses it crashed..cause at first u concentrate on chris martins vocals and then sum 41's voice come in and take over so maybe just sum41's beat with an coldplay acapella...sorry but thats my opinion......nice try though

aren't Sum 41 a Christian Rock band or something? meh !

sum 41's music are too punk or noisy.

oh really nice remix

it cant find the page :S

I don't like Sum45!!...I mean 41 :lol: :lol: :lol:

How do you access this file? I typed in my username and password, but it didn't accept it?

Hmm that is probably why I like the song then.. haha they should get sued though! :stunned:

The first 3 chords are the same as The Scientist, but the last one isn't. It still sounds very, very similiar. But I like the song :P

The first 3 chords are the same as The Scientist' date=' but the last one isn't. It still sounds very, very similiar. But I like the song :P[/quote']

Exactly. So, for example, lets say both songs are in the key of F. The Scientist goes Dm-Bb-F-C/F... if you listen to the bassline in the second verse it hangs on the F, doesnt change to C. Whereas in "Pieces" it changes to C/Em... not the same

Also the interlude in Pieces is nowhere near reminiscient of anything in the Scientist, especially when it hangs on the Am.

 

FYI, similar chord changes can be heard in so many other songs, just in different keys. The Dm-Bb-F-C chord progression is just in a different key than, say, Only One- Yellowcard, which has the same chord pattern, just a different tempo, key, and slight variations.

Heck, Lee Ann Womacks "I hope you dance" uses the same chord pattern (in the chorus) as Pieces.

If you wanna talk about close, listen to the Rolling Stone's "Anybody Seen My Baby" and KD Lang's "Constant Craving"... Actually I think the Stones got sued for that... Just saying that its physically impossible to be 100% original these days

How do you access this file? I typed in my username and password' date=' but it didn't accept it?[/quote']

 

as me and stix03 are painfully new members, we're both having the same problem. any help?

What a friggin joke. Unbelievable. But I guess that is what crappy bands with no talent do. Directly steal from other bands.

Question:

Is that lousy group worthy for talking about it in a Coldplay fan page?????

:confused: :lol:

The link is dead. Can anybody upload this one?