when X&Y came out some people said it wasn't as good as the other 2 albums so i want to know what you would think if ...

 

X&Y was Coldplay's first album then ROBTTH then Parachutes

 

would you still be saying that X&Y wasn't very good?

i know that obviously it would be weird because Coldplay's music has progressed .. but what would you think?

 

(thinking about making a 10 day poll for this ........

i'll make another best album poll to see if your opinion has changed from the last poll :D)

The first two albums (Parachutes and AROBTTH) are both great, but in fact that X&Y is a "Single-Album", ( every track from X&Y has the potential for release as a single ) I voted for X&Y.

 

All 3 albums are great. They continued their music from album to album.

i love all three records, but X&Y is my favourite at the moment :blush:

X&Y is my favourite at the moment, but I suppose its only cos its new. I still love Parachutes though and AROBTTH. :/

hmm tough one..

 

 

if X&Y were their first... I'd still dig it.. but I wouldn't be as 'hooked' as Parachutes grabbed me. I don't know why... its just a feeling I get. I still can't seem to find the right words to describe this new record... but I'm not in love with it as I was with Parachutes or AROBTTH.

No, I would still like Parachutes the best.

A Rush Of Blood To The Head, for me, then X & Y, then Parachutes.

AROBTTH is losing........ :cry:

I can't decide whether i like AROBTTH or X&Y better... but parachutes is deffinetly my least favorite...

It's suprising that AROBTTH is losing... i figured it would be at the top.... :embarrased:

oooo look at that all level! :stunned: .. just proves they're all great albums!

... heres my poll results from it .. this thread didn't really take off though :/