Seeing as these two songs are somewhat similar in style, which one do you think is better. I think The Scientist by hair. Fix You is no slouch however.

I do not think they are that similar. but the scientist is a little better.

I like fix you better, although I dont think they are that much alike.

I think there are some similarities:

Quiet first verse, then chorus. Acoustic guitar kicks in. Chorus. Fuzzy Guitar. Of course they are no that similar, but I think Fix is The Scientist of this album.

These two songs are nothing alike.... more would be What If and The Scientist.

 

Fix You is better though. ;)

Well fix you is missing a catchy piano riff and I've heard The Scientist about a million times more, so I dunno :huh:

The Scientist seems to have more emotion, both lyrically and sonically. So that's my vote.

Fix You compares more to Amsterdam is my opinion....but either way The Scientist rules them all :)

They are not that similair, fix you is more amsterdam or warning sign, but its tough to compare to the old stuff, because i think the band obviously made a concerted effort to move forward, so its gonna sound different....