has anyone else noticed that typically all critics praise this song as one of the album highlights, but among coldplay fans it is one of the least popular? what do you make of that?

 

I, personally, like the song a lot. It's not a favorite, but I do really dig it.

i love the song. its one of the ones i dont skip to go to the next. anyways yeah i hear when magazines talk about this song is that it is different from what coldplay would do and it sticks out from the rest of the album. to me it does kind of seem different from the rest of the songs on a rush'. i dont remember where i read this but i read that it reminds some people of maybe.....a pink floyd song? i dont know but its a great song! hey i even have the song going on in my head now as i type :shock: i think i'll listen to it now.

i like it a lot

plus critics don't know anything, they just write to make themselves feel good. why should their opinion be looked higher upon than any of ours?

yeah

i like it a lot

plus critics don't know anything, they just write to make themselves feel good. why should their opinion be looked higher upon than any of ours?

They shouldn't. I just thought it was interesting how opinions of the song differed from critics to fans.

well obviously the fans dont like or care what they say.

i really like a whisper although it isn't one of my favourites from arobtth. i guess the critics just singled that out from the others cos it's probably the furthest away from parachutes - but who knows how critics think? :?

thats what i was trying to say i just couldnt think of it

the critics are saying its far from parachute which makes it so out of place.

well obviously the fans dont like or care what they say.

 

just found this in an nme review of the libertines;

 

What the blazes is going on? Coldplay release the dreariest load of flu-rock tosh since Elbow and half the globe buys it,

 

:?: :?: :?: :?: :shock:

i dont know

i have something from spin magazine that i will put up later because i dont know where it is right now

i realy love a whisper its brilliant! but then again....arent they all :shrug: :roll:

i realy love a whisper its brilliant! but then again....arent they all :shrug: :roll:

yes they are :D

 

 

i couldnt name one song i dont like :o 8)

yeah i know

i kinda have that with both albums!

and with the b-sides aswell!

they are just fucking brilliant!!

A Whisper is great............ the only song that I have heard of CP so far, and I don't like it at all is Gop put a smile upon your face, but the live version is really good, I just don't like the one on the cd

A Whisper is great............ the only song that I have heard of CP so far, and I don't like it at all is Gop put a smile upon your face, but the live version is really good, I just don't like the one on the cd

double post :P:P just teasin you :D

Wow...this song is really grea.t..,I don't skip it anymore :)

ive never skipped it! i respect this song and i love it!!

i think this song is the least talked about song on the album...this or green eyes.

 

i like this song. it takes a couple of listens before you can commit to it i think. the first time i heard the beginnig i thought it was garbage.

*agrees* :)

its just...blargh!

It's the only Coldplay song that I really don't like. :shrug:

lmao ^ oh god, look at the happy couple! jess that av is great! :-D

Thanks! We just took that this morning :D

lol. good morning sunshines!