+ It is a tribute Johnny Cash, a legendary artist

- It is performed wayyyy better live

 

Crests of Waves

+ Good lyrics on paper

- Doesn't fit well as a song...bit disjointed I think...

 

A Message

+ Lovely guitar chords and riff.

- The word "love" is mentioned too much

 

Ladder To The Sun

Song: 'Til Kingdom Come

 

+Great lyrics and the acoustic sound is amazing.

- Doesn't really fit with the rest of the X&Y album

 

 

Next song: Gravity (studio version)

+ Chris sounds sexy here! Very emotional and intimate.

- a song best for earphones, not for blaring..

 

1.36

1'36''

 

+ It rocks, the music is very cool

- It's too short

 

Swallowed in the Sea

Swallowed in the Sea

 

glad they did it in their twisted logic tour!

 

+ Beautifully simple buliding up to a wonderful point, that really gets to your soul! love the ending!

- not really a negative; is definately an overlooked song, could have been realesed as a single!

 

Next: Sleeping Sun

er...

+ its a coldplay song

- ive neaver heard of it

 

politik

+great intro and lyrics

-kinda repetative

 

A Whisper

+ The outro is phenomenal when headphnes are pressed into your ears...

- Underappreciated song!

 

What's Going On

+GREAT vocals...GREAT melody

-lyrics are ... just good. Not Coldplay good.

 

Harmless

+ nice lyrics, glad there was a full version

- maybe an alternate ending?

 

Brothers and Sisters (Trouble Ep Version) (Primary)

+great lyrics , kinda revolutionar to me

- i can' t remember right now....

 

solid ground

+ Lovely simple song with sweet lyrics

- Just Chris and a piano

 

White Shadows

+ beautiful lyrics

- should have been a single

 

amsterdam

+perfect music n lyrics

-needed one more verse...lol.

 

All Good Things w/Chris?

+ I love the chatter at the beginning! Chris & Nelly sound really good together. Very catchy. Oh and nice lyrics and guitar chords...a lot really :laugh4:

- Wish I could hear the chatter a bit better...and who could forget...EMI :rolleyes: :dozey:

 

Yellow Piano Version

+Deep, true, inspired

-a bit disturbing...must be all the low chords we're not used to in the original.

^^you forgot a post a song

 

sleeping sun

+ A happy song. Love the simplicity of the song and acoustic guitar riffs. The breathing at the end tops it off :nice:

- Too short.

 

Amsterdam

+ Fantastic, fragile, haunting song...my favourite non rocky CP song

- Not played live enough!

 

Speed Of Sound

+ Great seeing it live, catchy, all piano based songs are good.

- Sounds a bit reminiscent to Clocks (not really a bad thing)

 

Twisted Logic

+ Love it. Best song on X&Y.

- They never play it live. :angry:

 

ETA: Whoops! Forgot to add a song!

 

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face

+ One of their best songs live, great bass riff, Johnny rocks in the end part

- If I had to pick at something, the drumming is a bit uncreative, but I think the simplicity of it is perfect.

 

Trouble?

+ good song, like video aswell

- it makes me think of spiders. you have to let it grow on you.

 

spies