+beautiful song, I love the guitars

-Maybe the lyrics? no I like the lyrics... I don't know, there's some weakness just can't put my finger on what exactelly it is..

 

i bloom blaum?

+ good lyrics

- kinda boring and unfinished

In The Sun

+ Great collaboration and great song for a great cause

- Gets old after a while, but still good!

Oops, forgot a new song hehe...

 

Um, White Shadows.

+really cool opening with the disco-type vibe

-very similar to the other songs on the CD, though better than most of them

 

proof?

+ great lyrics

- repeatative

 

Shiver

+ perfect lyrics

- nothing :)

Next:

 

Daylight

+absolutely brilliant. i love the slide guitar and the piano chords...its just so wonderful. it makes me think of morning and i looove it.

- everywhere ive seen, the lyrics are printed as "ooh, when the sun shines/yeah, on this heart of mine", but i actually think they are "ooh, when the sun shines/yeah, on this coal mine". there arent enough syllables for it to be the first one!!

then again, im probably wrong.

 

next: talk (demo)

+ Better than album version

- They should have kept it!

 

Green Eyes

+lovely song, i hope it was written for jonny...

-its a bit repetative, and its possible it wasnt written for jonny...

 

i ran away

+ everything fits together properly

- ???

 

Sleeping Sun?

+ i absolutely love this one, different is definately one of the positives

- kinda goes nowhere, but i think thats why i love it, very simple

 

Clocks the live X&Y tour version, ie on the dutch talk 3 cd. the one where it get fast at the end and also has the intro

+ Superb. Absolutely blew me away at Earl's Court. A sonic orgasm. :P

- Nothing whatsoever...

 

Gravity (Talk Single Version)

+ vocals and piano great

- a little bit too slow

 

'Til Kingdom Come?

+ emotional

- the drum...

 

 

 

A whisper

+ good chorus

- hard to no what hes saying....lol!

 

X&Y?

+ good lyrics, good outro

- bad intro

 

Green Eyes?

+ sentimental (reminds me of a I've met that has green eyes....)

- the drums could be strengthened somehow....

 

 

 

High speed

+ Wonderful lyrics and bassline

- Should be done live a lot more

 

Parachutes

+ great to play in my ax

- too short...

 

 

 

For you

+ pianos

- Chris's voice is too low

 

Low?

+ great drums

- maybe too long

 

 

 

Politik

+really good concert song, gets you pumped, love the middle bit where it gets more intense with guitars. and good message.

-not that brillaint musically. its just a lot of banging on the same note, then shifting a few notes and banging on that one.

 

in the sun

Man... why was this thread abandoned since 2006? This is a great game! :D Why not bring it back?

 

+ Very beautiful, great piano, and a great collab. :D

- Can't hear enough of Chris... although it's a bit of a strech to call this a minus, since the main voice singing it is a great replacement.

 

Paradise