Alrighty, which one is the right one?!!??!!?

[a101stad]

This is really getting on me.... there is a lot of fake music sheets out there, even the one in the instrument room. I'm not sure if its just my playing, that I'm playing wrong, or its the music sheet itself.

 

Now I need help... which one is right?!?!?! ( I'm suppose to test it I know by myself, but I'm too lazy :( ):

 

They are all Lost? Btw

 

 

 

 

 

[Twizted Logik]

 

 

 

 

 

This one is pretty darn accurate.

[princesanji]

i agree with Twizted Logik.

 

the last one is trash. the first one... well, we know the sheet books, good shot, not perfect, though it's Lost! and not Lost?, so actually you cannot compare them. the second and third ones are the best.

[Twizted Logik]

The second is better than the third though, as it shows all the bass notes being played, whereas the third just shows the root notes.

[TheBigC]

The first one from the full book is the one i scanned and uploaded. Its from the PVG, which is more of an "Easy piano" version that plays the vocals.

 

The second one is the one I bought on musicnotes and uploaded. It is the actual instrumental piano transcription, and is the most accurate that I've found.

[adamschoales]

Also want to confirm: first is the piano book which is in the style that is popular these days: add the melody line instead of teaching you what the artist is actually playing (which is odd considering the first three coldplay books were are SHOCKINGLY accurate). its also for Lost! (you can find Lost? in the Prospekt's March book which is also on here, but be forewarned... it too is not all that accurate, especially when you get to the big octaves).

 

The second one is the closest we've got so far. However personally I find it to be very poorly layed-out. If theres one good thing about the officially book its the larger notes, and chord boxes. The online book is harder to read (smaller notes) and doesn't have the big chord boxes. That said, it comes closer/closest to what you hear on the album. If only they'd do the PM book now...

[a101stad]

Thanks guys/gals :)

[PianoRocker]

Never stick on one sheet.

Most Coldplay sheets are wrong or just realy weird.

 

Just try to find good chords(if you're ears aint trained yet.)

And try to get the good playing with these chords.

After a time try to find out the chords your're self.

Later you don't need sheet music and get the perfects way of playing all by yourself.

[adamschoales]

Never stick on one sheet.

Most Coldplay sheets are wrong or just realy weird.

 

Just try to find good chords(if you're ears aint trained yet.)

And try to get the good playing with these chords.

After a time try to find out the chords your're self.

Later you don't need sheet music and get the perfects way of playing all by yourself.

 

This is where the Viva/PM books actually do come in handy: the chord boxes seem to all be accurate. Using those you can do your own arrangement, similar to Chris' "Acoustic Piano" versions. That's what I've been doing.

[PianoRocker]

This is where the Viva/PM books actually do come in handy: the chord boxes seem to all be accurate. Using those you can do your own arrangement, similar to Chris' "Acoustic Piano" versions. That's what I've been doing.

Some are great but some chords are completely crap.