well first of, if it fits better another section, mods be free to move it,

secondly, if there's already an existing thread, feel free to merge it.

 

general question:

 

what you consider will make an artist be the best?

 

his/her behave on stage?

his/her attitude with their fans?

his/ her voice, lyrics, music?

his/her personal life?

combination of those 4 things, any other?

 

please, do explain your answers.

 

ex.:

his/her behave on stage cause is energetic and expressive....

 

discuss.

Music reflects everything, it's lyrics and melodies that blow you away, I don't care if they don't sign me an autograph as long as they come with an excellent record. I don't care if they are shine on stage or do not show up much, unless we are talking about models. Personal life may affect alittle, but it's not the most important. I mean if I suddenly heard my fav is a murder I would stop buying his stuff, but would not stop listening to him

Music reflects everything, it's lyrics and melodies that blow you away, I don't care if they don't sign me an autograph as long as they come with an excellent record. I don't care if they are shine on stage or do not show up much, unless we are talking about models. Personal life may affect a little, but it's not the most important. I mean if I suddenly heard my fav is a murder I would stop buying his stuff, but would not stop listening to him

What Ricardo says ... the music should be the best .. otherwise I can't be bothered - even if he's the hottest/nicest guy on the planet ¬¬

interesting answer ricardo.

 

so if an artist were a murder, you would still listen to the artist works (i guess you refer to the previous works of which you already own a copy).

 

so for you the most important is that the artist is talented.

musical skills only i guess.

so you don't care much if is expressive or not?

Expressive on stages and interviews?

Expressive on stages and interviews?

generally with their work (lyrics, instruments).

No yes, both talent and feelin are what really mattwr

it's most definitely their music for me. It can express so much...

judge artists by their art.

music. But playing good live can really boost me liking them...

judge artists by their art.

he explained better, and more simple

judge artists by their art.

right that, but if a good artist who does a good art does bizarre/ilegal things, would you sitll consider is a good artist? :thinking:

An artist is a good artist based on how he/she/they performs/perform the songs... and connect with the crowd :nice: