What do you think?

Their sets are much shorter live, and X&Y is easily their worst album.

definitely not as good AROBTTH. I do like the songs better live. I'll have a definite answer in 2 weeks after the show. I got a taste of the live on Storytellers, and I was convinced it was going to be a great album... I was wrong. I don't even find myself listening to this one as much.. and when I do, I am constantly skipping tracks. I think they really struggled with this album. And its an overall good album.. but not by AROBTTH standards. That album broke new ground... it was fresh, different, and versatile. This album is just over produced. In my opinion.

The album is overproduced so I voted for worst studio, better live.

They have improved in both their live performance and in the studio. I haven't seen them on previous tours but watched their Manchester concert from 2002 on MTV. They have changed their live performance slightly and I'm still not a fan of their black outfits. In the studio: even though I was slightly disappointed with the new album it has grown on me and I prefer it to AROBTTH.

Definately not as good as ARoBttH but X&Y is still good, even better live!

The album is overproduced so I voted for worst studio' date=' better live.[/quote']

 

exactly

I kinda see what they're doing as a permanent improvement, so better studio, better live.

i think they've improved in the studio. i think they're great live at the moment too. they may even get better towards the end of the tour

Their sets are much shorter live' date=' and X&Y is easily their worst album.[/quote']

 

I agree, but even it being their worst album its still a really good one...

Eh, I said Better/Better. Took me a couple of listens to X&Y for it grow on me, but overall I like it. Live, they just keep getting better! :D

Better Live and in Studio......they always add something new a song,when its being performed live......

I like ARoBttH's more acoustic feel, but I love X&Y also... I like 'em equally... I can't really say it's better or worse, but I'll just put better for kicks. :)

 

And live, I love 'em more. :)

Better Studio and better Live. I straight-up loved X&Y!

actually i prefer x&y......the songs are really great and i admit that arobtth is good too but i think x&y is better....

but my favourite is parachutes.... :D

worse studio, better live