i myself think the leaked version is better.

lyrically definitely the leaked one is better, but it's not complete in my opinion (strange sound). so i choose the album version i think. but i have to admit if that version wasn't leaked and Coldplay would finish it, maybe that one'd be better by miles.

I have no doubts about it; I find the leaked version much better than the album one, for the lyrics, but especially for the melody, is more magical and accoustic...

what a pity that they haven't included it on the album although I think at least they would have included it as a single with the released version (both), as well...

the leaked version is amazing, but I still prefer the released version... ;)

I always prefered the leaked version...but I'm not sure anymore...because talk is just getting on my nerves at the moment...it was played too often on the radio!

i'm going for the leaked on ...

the lyrics are just amazing and waaaaay better than the released one ...

however ... i think that the musical arrangement of the released version is better

the bridge and guitar eruption on the leaked Talk is one of Coldplay's most powerful moments. certainly a dissapointment that it wasn't released, but hey, most of what I heard from x&y was a dissapointment to begin with.

The leaked version is way better. They're both great, but the leaked version is so much more powerful and poignant.

at first i liked leaked version but then i begin to like released one

I would say I like the lyrics of the leaked version and the melody of the released eheh....so I can't vote anything :P

..*coughs* ne body got the leaked version?? if so could u share it with me in a PM?? :)

The released one.

I prefer the leaked version.

I know many people like the leaked version better, but I had to vote released, simply because the released version has much more cohesiveness. The leaked version sounds patched together and I don't much like the lyrics. They sound hokey.

..*coughs* ne body got the leaked version?? if so could u share it with me in a PM?? :)

 

yeah the only version leaked that i heard was talk. If we are talking about that I like both acually...the leaked one alittle more but the released on I got used to

I like the leaked version, but the released version is just so elegantly driven and it's one of the best written songs I've ever heard. It's hard to beat the released version but the demo comes close.