April 18, 201115 yr I've narrowed it down but putting them in order is going to be difficult, as it fluctuates. But I'll do my best. :wacko: I still don't know how it won't be obvious who made the lists though, I could see the YouTube channels from the Beatles lists. Oh well, I suppose it's not a huge deal. I assume that the people submitting a list are NOT supposed to vote on the lists?
April 18, 201115 yr oh people will definitely be able to vote on the lists. Depending how many we get it'll be like 3 threads or something of say 4 different lists. Then who ever wins that thread will face the winners of the other threads. I still have to talk to Greg though for voting. I mean I think it will be okay to vote for your own but i have to see. either way we'll figure out the voting scheme and then post the rules on it when the time comes.
April 18, 201115 yr I don't think people should be able to vote on their own lists. That's just my opinion, though.
April 18, 201115 yr Author Yeah, you can't vote for your own, and if you do it doesn't count and everyone you are against gets a point, unless you grovel haha. That'll stop people trying to sneak it, since we are trying to keep each playlist a secret to stop tactical voting. Whoever organises the thread, so in the Radiohead case Mike, and also the playlist maker should be the only people who know which one is theirs. So in this thread Mike will have to keep a beady eye (no we will not be doing a Beady Eye top 15) on the votes.
April 18, 201115 yr yeah good idea. i will be putting down who's playlist is who's, especially for the voting choices, and keeping a close eye... so no one will be able to get by and vote for their own.
April 18, 201115 yr Author Mines done and even I don't agree with it. I've possibly made it too personalised which means it won't win because you guys aren't me, but I surprised myself with having no b-sides.
April 18, 201115 yr I've possibly made it too personalised which means it won't win because you guys aren't me Well I think that's the point, right? I feel the same about mine, but that's the point. Unless we're supposed to be making a list of what we think should be viewed as the top 15 Radiohead songs, as opposed to our favorite 15 (because those wouldn't necessarily yield the same result). :uhoh:
April 18, 201115 yr I've made mine pretty personalised, too, esp. since it is really hard to choose a TOP 15.....some albums are left out in my list (did I say too much now?)
April 18, 201115 yr Author Well I think that's the point, right? I feel the same about mine, but that's the point. Unless we're supposed to be making a list of what we think should be viewed as the top 15 Radiohead songs, as opposed to our favorite 15 (because those wouldn't necessarily yield the same result). :uhoh: I considered doing them as the best written 15 songs, but I went for my favourite.
April 18, 201115 yr Okay then, it looks like everybody is doing their personal favorite 15. It seems that we're being consistent.
April 18, 201115 yr I felt tempted to troll my list, just because I don't think they will differ greatly.
April 18, 201115 yr My list is definitely not for their best songs. My list is more just what songs I enjoy the most.
April 19, 201115 yr Author Yeah, yours might be the most popular with the non-fans since you haven't had long for all the songs to settle yet :p
April 19, 201115 yr Yeah, yours might be the most popular with the non-fans since you haven't had long for all the songs to settle yet :p trust me... mine doesn't look like a noobie list edit: Wait... aren't YOU the one who said he doesn't have any b-sides on his list? Methinks yours will look more noob than mine: Mines done and even I don't agree with it. I've possibly made it too personalised which means it won't win because you guys aren't me, but I surprised myself with having no b-sides.
Create an account or sign in to comment