I like stealing thread ideas.....

 

 

This should provide some interesting discussion for a while.

Put a list of however many you want (But not past 20.)

 

Any type of musician, instrumentalist, vocalist etc.

 

OK, this is very hard, I'll admit, but I'll try.

 

And this includes a lot of people that are just my personal prefernece that would never be considered on an official list.

 

1. Dave Grohl (Foo Fighters, Nirvana, Queens of the Stone Age [sorta], Probot)

2. Jonny Greenwood (Radiohead)

3. Eric Clapton (Mainly solo but also: Cream, The Yardbirds, probably more..)

4. Thom Yorke (Radiohead)

5. John Bonham (Led Zeppelin)

6. Angus Young (AC/DC)

7. George Harrison (The Beatles)

8. Robert Plant (Led Zeppelin)

9. John Butler (John Butler Trio)

10. Chris Martin (Coldplay)

 

That's all I can think of right now.

 

That'll change very soon probably, and you can edit your lists because I'll count them up on the 31st.

 

Oh and include band names where you can.

nice one Sam!

 

1. Thom Yorke (Radiohead)

2. Elliott Smith (solo, ex-Heatmiser)

3. John Lennon (The Beatles)

4. Wayne Coyne (The Flaming Lips)

5. Billy Joel

6. Bob Dylan

7. Eric Clapton (solo, ex-Yardbirds)

8. Jonny Greenwood (Radiohead)

9. Ray Charles

10. Freddie Mercury (Queen)

Hopefully it doesn't die.

I started with my post, but I realised it's too hard. Good luck for those who are willing to try

haha, yeah it's pretty hard.

No question at all who should be number one...

 

1. Paul McCartney

 

wothout him, and the rest of the Beatles, no one would be where they are today. But the rest of the list was hard to put together...here's my try.

 

2. Jimi Hendrix

3. George Harrison

4. Paul Simon

5. John Lennon

6. Frank Sinatra

7. Eric Clapton

8. Bob Dylan

9. James Talyor

10. Jeff Buckley

 

For the most part, it's pretty standard...a few suprises, I suppose, but I think to qualify for All Time, an artist has to stand the test of time. And I think everyone here qualifies.

Well this will be edited over time:

 

1. The Edge

2.

^there's some deep thinking going on there.

1.David Gilmour

2.Roger Waters

3.Paul McCartney

4.Thom Yorke

5.Eric Clapton

6.Jimi Hendrix

7.Ozzy Osborne

8.Billy Corgan

9.Bono

10.Dave Matthews

1. Chris Martin :)

2. Thom Yorke

3. John Lennon

4. Bono

5.Freddie Mercury

6. The Edge

...

It's amazing how one person says someone that probably a lot of people wouldn't think of and then other's amazingly they appear in other people's lists. Not saying that about this thread in particular, just in general.

OK from now on can any people include any bands (if any) that that musician is in. Cheers.

:thinking:

Sorry, just for the mentally inactive I will edit it for you. Even though you seem to be the only one who has the disability to understand what it means and it does actually make sense how it is.

 

And please: post a list, I would love to see how your musical taste fairs.

:thinking:

 

Oh My Friggin God, you had to friggin edit your post to a friggin smiley to try to hide how stupid you are, you really are a friggin tool!!!!!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Idiot.

Just because some of the musicians that are in others ppls list are in mine only means that I too think they should be in my list,nothing to do with copying!!

Oh My Friggin God, you had to friggin edit your post to a friggin smiley to try to hide how stupid you are, you really are a friggin tool!!!!!

Idiot.

 

I wasn't the one who screwed up the thread title in the first place and had to go and change it!;)

Obviously once you did, the post in question was no longer appropriate.:cool:

I never said it was Rickyo :wink2:

:nice:

 

And^^^^:lol: :lol:

I wasn't the one who screwed up the thread title in the first place and had to go and change it!;)

Obviously once you did, the post in question was no longer appropriate.:cool:

 

It was entitled "Top Musicians of All Time (Closed 31 June)".

 

Now, when it says closed 31 June, it means it will be closed 31 June, not it was closed 31 June. I believe you may have your calendar screwed up or something you poor child.

 

Also take note you are the only one who interpretted it in this way, sorta tells you something doesn't it?

Why do you always look for a fight?? Do you not have anything better to do with your time?

Me? because you better not mean me *shakes fist* why I oughta.....

 

 

But seriously, you did not see what Mark posted so don't go counting your chickens...

I was of course refering to Mark,sorry should have said that in my post!!

It was entitled "Top Musicians of All Time (Closed 31 June)".

 

Now, when it says closed 31 June, it means it will be closed 31 June, not it was closed 31 June. I believe you may have your calendar screwed up or something you poor child. quote]

 

Well where I come from the future and past are completely different tenses, although of course that might be different where you are, I suppose.:rolleyes:

Ok, that's fine then. :nice: