I'll just copy Mike's post from the RH top 15 :P

 

This is the Arcade Fire top 10 songs thread to see what people agree with most on this forum. For this I am going to have 3 separate threads, the first one having 4 and each one after containing 3 peoples lists. From there whomever wins each one of these threads will then move onto round 2, where everyone will then vote again for the best song list.

 

Rules:

-You CAN'T vote for your own list (I know who's list is who's so if I see that you voted for your own, your vote will be disqualified)

-You CAN'T say which list is yours. You can discuss which lists you like, but these are meant to be anonymous.

 

 

Voting will last for a week whomever gets the most votes wins in the thread. Vote until Fri, May 27.

 

 

The lists are below.

 

Choice A

 

1. Cold Wind

2. Neighbourhood #1 (Tunnels)

3. Wake Up

4. My Body Is A Cage

5. The Suburbs

6. Sprawl ii (Mountains Beyond Mountains)

7. No Cars Go

8. Haiti

9. Ready To Start

10. Rebellion (Lies)

 

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKU82yHCLGs&list=PL1008B6E93A4094D5]YouTube - ‪Cold Wind - The Great Arcade Fire‬‏[/ame]

 

Choice B

 

1. Une Année Sans Lumiere

2. My Body is a Cage

3. City with No Children

4. Intervention

5. Brazil

6. Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)

7. Sprawl I (Flatland)

8. Keep the Car Running

9. Half Light II (No Celebration)

10. Wake Up

 

 

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJPgkwYMpWY&list=PLBF90B504A7F2F097]YouTube - ‪Arcade Fire- Une Anee Sans Lumiere‬‏[/ame]

 

Choice C

 

 

1. Rebellion (Lies)

2. Neighborhood #3

3. Sprawl II

4. The Well and the Lighthouse

5. Haiti

6. Crown of Love

7. Black Mirror

8. Ready to Start

9. My Heart is an Apple

10. No Cars Go

 

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-8nQw-oV5o&feature=BFp&list=PLC2B855D40F6FA51B]YouTube - ‪The Arcade Fire - Rebellion (Lies) (HQ)‬‏[/ame]

Sweet, some more varied lists than I expected.

Yeah, those lists are completely different.

Yeah, those lists are completely different.

 

Not one song appears on all three!

haha yeah that's weird

 

 

 

I went with choice A

Should I sticky the polls?

I'm not sure how it was with the Radiohead-polls.

 

I don't mind either way. :)

yeah if you could thatd be great! we did that for the RH ones

Okay, stickied.

We still need poll no. 3!

I'm waiting for a PM to post that thread

What's the issue? :p

someone posted the same song twice on the list :lol:

Haha. Oh dear.

Unless it was The Suburbs, but still we need to know which is which.

No it wasn't The Suburbs

I'm sure they'll reply soon. Give them till the end of the week, and we can have a small overlap between the end of these votes, and this one to catch up. No problem. If they don't get back to you by the end of this voting then they'll have to be dropped though.

voted for C.

I went with A, but my ideal list would have more Funeral in it. :P

 

Also, Tunnels is obviously the best AF song. ;)

*shakes head* No "in the backseat". Y'all suck.

Definitely had to go with choice A. Four of the songs on that list would be in my personal top 5 favorite AF songs: Rebellion, Sprawl II, Neighborhood #1, and My Body Is A Cage.

I had never heard Brazil before. :surprised:

 

I like Cold Wind but I don't see how you could think it's the best Arcade Fire song (since putting it n°1 on the list is what it suggests)...

 

I went for choice C even though none of the lists fully satisfy me.

*shakes head* No "in the backseat". Y'all suck.

 

Mine has that in and only has one vote haha.

I didn't include it in mine but probably it'd be in my top 15 I guess

It's the only song she sings in that I love.

I like Black Wave/Bad Vibrations, but only especially when she shuts up.

It's the only song she sings in that I love.

I like Black Wave/Bad Vibrations, but only especially when she shuts up.

 

this

I hate Black Wave/Bad Vibrations

Haiti and Sprawl II are my favorite Regine songs :dazzled: :