-As for the lyrics from MX onward, I completely agree. Most of the time in the old days they used to write such beautiful lyrics.. what happened? I mean, they were great before, what happened between Viva and MX that could possibly cause him to write such worse lyrics? I really hope he gets back on track with AHFOD.
-IMO, even though MX and GS has not-so-hot lyrics, at least for MX as far as I'm concerned the sound is so beautiful and great in most songs that it still makes up for the bad lyrics, just like the few times it happened before the MX era. As for GS, well.... there are some songs that have a good enough melody to them to fix the bad lyrics but, well, as for some of the other songs in GS... Again, as you said, hopefully every problem is fixed in AHFOD that they do have now, and with GS, IMO, GS is them really starting to go downhill. They do have graet songs, don't get me wrong, but the richness that they had before isn't in the GS songs, it doesn't sound as legitimate IMO... it kind of sounds plastic-y. The melody's are great and I do kind of like the sound, but that's one thing, I like it. I don't love it. It's pretty good, and so are the melodies in some instances but other times the sound just doesn't sound as good as before, and the melodys are quite less as creative as before too.
-I really do agree. I am still am emotionally connected with a lot of the songs in GS but if they didn't have as much of that squeaky clean pop plastic sound in there I think that'd help me enjoy it a lot more. There are some songs that kind of fit with it though and I really do like them with that sound, but it would be better with a real sound to it. This really starts to get on me in GS and beyond, in GS it is plastic-y. I still very much enjoy it, it'd just be better with legit sounds. Miracles just sounds really clean and poppy IMO... but it still has a good melody to it. Then again, it was just a movie soundtrack so I guess it didn't matter too much to us there. Gone But Not has a great melody, a very good melody. But it has such a clean sound to it... I do enjoy it but still it'd be better with some of the Oldplay sound in it though.
-That's alright. Everyone has their own opinion... IMO Ink has a good melody and it's one of the better songs in GS. It does even have a bit of flaws in it too which makes the melody even better sounding (again, minor flaws as you said make the songs even more rich), although it doesn't use that good Oldplay sound that is so rich, the sound they use in that song isn't as deep, it's kind of shallow and doesn't go as deep as the Oldplay sound. I still very much enjoy it though, As for True Love, welllll.... haven't listened to it much, but I guess it's good.