Aaaaaargh! i saw both CDs in the shop yesterday and didn't know which one to buy! :bigcry: Aaaaaah, vote for me, please! :wacko:

My choice is My Iron Lung because The Bends era is my favourite by Radiohead although Takk is probably the best SR album,Radiohead is a little better band IMO

takk. imo one of the best albums in the last 10 years, i don't think my iron lung is at the same level...

My iron lung! I have it..the songs on it are great! Its great to listen to that album.

My Iron Lung is more rarer than Takk, so I will buy Takk.

 

But bearing in mind, I live near a town which is now a music desert, where anything not in the chart is near impossible to buy :(

My Iron Lung is more rarer than Takk' date=' so I will buy Takk.[/quote']

 

I don't understand : you buy the less rare ?

 

I'd buy My Iron Lung because it's rarer.

 

 

But Takk is great.

 

But MIL is good too : Trickster, Punchdrunk, Lozenge, Wash Up : great songs, esp Trickster. Well i actually find My Iron Lung is the poorest song on the disc...

 

My Iron Lung. You'll get Takk later.

 

@ Rad-Cold. My Iron Lung is an EP, not an album.

I said it was rarer, I didn't say it was better :P

Takk!

I don't understand : you buy the less rare ?

 

I'd buy My Iron Lung because it's rarer.

 

 

But Takk is great.

 

But MIL is good too : Trickster, Punchdrunk, Lozenge, Wash Up : great songs, esp Trickster. Well i actually find My Iron Lung is the poorest song on the disc...

 

My Iron Lung. You'll get Takk later.

 

@ Rad-Cold. My Iron Lung is an EP, not an album.

 

Doh uim sure she knows about it since Radiohead is her favourite band

I haven't really listened to SR that much. But I do have the My Iron Lung EP and I was pleasantly surprised at how great it is. I think I enjoy MIL EP more than Airbag/How Am I Driving

Make sure to bring enough money next time and buy BOTH.

 

It's INSANE having to choose between those two.

I agree with RadioMad.

Picking between the two is like trying to decide if you like your left foot or your right foot more. Both are essential. :D

Takk! i have the iron lung ep so i'd go for takk haha :P

I have both I love both, but given the choice again, I'd go with Takk. The ep is great, but it is mainly a collection of b-sides. Takk is a full album and a cohesive masterpiece.

 

At the very least Takk has more songs. ;)

takk. of course. lol ah so biased since i've never listened to the other but you can never go wrong with sigur ros ;)

It's INSANE having to choose between those two.

 

That's a point.

Buy Takkk...

 

...and Steal My Iron Lung ;)

Yeah, you know... it's really hard! MIL is for 10€ and Takk is for 18€ ... :\

 

I dunno ... I'd buy Takk mostly because of 3 songs (Glosoli, Hopipolla and Saeglopur) and MIL because of Lozenge of Love, The Trickster, PLS and ... well .... probably because of every other song :D

buy MIL, it's harder to find.

you can always go back and pick up Takk later.

Or wait for Takk's price to be cut for any promo ocasion.

Good plan, as €18 (about £12,50) is a tad expensive for a 2 year old CD.

yeah... i'll probably buy MIL ... 18€ is too expensice for a low student budget.

If your budget is really that tight, you should just download them both and not to worry about buying them.

but i want to have some originals ;)

Ask for them for Christmas presents?