ok I take that back.. Elliot rocked!!!

I'm watching! I watch the show more out of habit than anything else.

 

Has Taylor Hicks gone yet? He's my favorite. That guy's nuts!! LMFAO! I want him to bust out his harmonica again, that was really cool.

 

Mandisa (or however you spell it?) was amazing last night, wasn't she? I don't usually get blown away by anyone on American Idol, but that was the first time a performance ended and I thought about rewinding my TIVO. Then Simon said that and I was like "whoa."

 

 

....OMG I missed Taylor!!!! :(

Taylor was pretty good... safe in my opinion.... the best tonight in my opinion was Elliot and Taylor...

It's only on now in Ireland. I know who the top 10 are though. I love Elliott, but don't like him choosing to sing heaven. Like Taylor and Chris too.

 

I like Kellie and Catherine from the girls group, but Paris is good too.

i hope taylor wins...how many 29 year olds w/ gray hair do you see in this industry...none...he's a decent singer and he stands out in a good way.

this girl completely butchered Stevie Wonder.... she needs to be shot. :stunned:

I cannot believe that no one else watching this crap.... c'mon people!!!!! Chicken Little got booted!! yay!!

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

 

I loved Kevin

Man,it's spoiled for me ,I was gonna have to wait like 2 weeks til it was showed over here :bigcry:

Yay! It was past time for Kevin to go byebye

He just couldn't compete with a sexy piece of man like Chris. Chris and Elliot get my vote. :)

Chris,Katharine and Mandisa are IT for me

 

(please if any of them has left the show after Melissa don't tell me, I'll talk about it when it happens over here which should be around 2 weeks from now)

i def want chris to win.... that "walk the line" was amazing!

Yeah he's a great singer and a hottie

ditto, but I'd like for katharine to win

Yeah I kind of like her too. I think out of all the girls though, Mandisa has the best voice.

She's amazing but I like Kathy better, she's a trained voice but also so natural....and nice. I think I might be in love with her.

She has amazing hair

you're totally right! I used to like Lisa but she's gonna go down soon, she's been at the bottom 3 for 2 weeks in a row.

My final 4 would be: Mandisa, Katharine, Chris and Ace/Elliot

Chris Katherine & Elliott my favourites

Yeah I agree with you guys

Anyways what do you guys think about Kellie Pickler?

Yeah I agree with you guys

Anyways what do you guys think about Kellie Pickler?

 

I actually liked her in the beggining, it's obvious she can sing, but now she has the whole small town-poor me-my dad's in jail character and I hate it. Oh, and I hate her accent

Yeah I know. It seems like she's trying to act all innocent but she's really not.

Exactly. I mean, is it necessary to talk about how your dad's in jail, you live with your grandpa and you were raised by people not related to you- over and over and over again?? WE KNOW! Then she starts crying because she didn't have any money while growing up bla bla bla yati yata...C'mon!

Yep, she's getting the pity vote. And the teenage male vote lol

I think she's getting the teenage female vote too. Now that Kevin's out ( :bigcry: ) there's a website called 'vote for the worst' or something like it and they're cheering for Kelly

Bitch

that Pickler girl is an idiot!! I hope she goes soon.....