I prefer IMP to A whisper.

i prefer In My Place, but A Whisper is lovely as well :wacky:

how can u hate those two songs?! IMP is the only reason there was a Post- Parachutes Coldplay! its an incredible song and I completely agree with all the good things said about The Goldrush. I also think Twisted Logic was cool because it has a different message than a lot of coldplay songs, it was about something more important than most sort of like violet hill. And the name is really great too. X&Y was also a great song, maybe it didnt fit the album but i love the song. My least favorite song would have to be....Easy to Please, and i still like to listen to it if i want a really soft song. i love the lyrics, hate the rest

Although I love In My Place and The Goldrush, I really really really love A Whisper. It's got this incredible atmosphere about it, and I think it is far more difficult to create a song like this than IMP or TG... Damn, I love AROBTTH and its dark gems. Not many of them dark songs after that album,eh? I also love Daylight too :)

I hate A Whisper

I hate using the word 'hate', but... pretty close to what you said. A Whisper is the only song on AROBTTH that I regularly skip. :|

 

EDIT: I take that back, I often skip Daylight too.

 

Exactly! It sounds like an ultimate jam session and is very real!

 

Reading the comments on this page though I think I might be the biggest Goldrush fan on the planet!

I love it too, when it comes on I usually hit repeat at least 3 times.

I love them all- but prefer IMP live in concert- just the anthemic factor, makes it fun to sing along during the show.

ya i like daylight more, especially at the end, but if i had to rate arobtth in order itd be:

 

1. The Scientist

2. Amsterdam

3. In My Place

4. Green Eyes

5. AROBTTH

6. Polotik

7. GPASUYF

8. Warning Sign

9. Clocks

10. Daylight

11. A Whisper

 

dang, its great to get down to listing ur least few songs on the album and still go to all of them "aw man thats an amazing song too!"...

ya i like daylight more, especially at the end, but if i had to rate arobtth in order itd be:

 

1. The Scientist

2. Amsterdam

3. In My Place

4. Green Eyes

5. AROBTTH

6. Polotik

7. GPASUYF

8. Warning Sign

9. Clocks

10. Daylight

11. A Whisper

 

dang, its great to get down to listing ur least few songs on the album and still go to all of them "aw man thats an amazing song too!"...

 

I don't even know where I'd start with that album. I think I'd have at least 8 songs at number 1!

exactly! ^^ and AROBTTH is only my second favorite album....

I love how this thread ended up in everyone spitting their guts about bad songs :P

IMP all the way. A Whisper is actually my least favorite Coldplay song, lol.

In My Place. A Whisper is ok...I like on bits of it because it mentions other Coldplay song titles in it.

I love both songs!!!!

More like Twisted Logic which is a damp disappointment of a song.

Oh wow I am not listening to your opinions anymore :blank:

But goldrush is so fun! That's why I love it. Just cuz it makes me imagine the boys having fun together, not trying to make a good or bad song :D

 

I think theeeeee same! =D

 

ya i like daylight more, especially at the end, but if i had to rate arobtth in order itd be:

 

1. The Scientist

2. Amsterdam

3. In My Place

4. Green Eyes

5. AROBTTH

6. Polotik

7. GPASUYF

8. Warning Sign

9. Clocks

10. Daylight

11. A Whisper

 

dang, its great to get down to listing ur least few songs on the album and still go to all of them "aw man thats an amazing song too!"...

 

Except for A Whisper (that for me, it's the low point of AROBTTH) and for Clocks (that is my favorite song of all time), I wouldn't be able to rank the rest of the songs! Congrats! hahaha

I like both songs, but IMP is better. :wacky:

I think theeeeee same! =D

 

 

 

Except for A Whisper (that for me, it's the low point of AROBTTH) and for Clocks (that is my favorite song of all time), I wouldn't be able to rank the rest of the songs! Congrats! hahaha

 

Don't you just feel like singing and dancing along with them :P haha I do, and my sister joins me :D

"...there's a tiny little crackle on the telephone liiiiiinnneee!..."

 

I agree clocks is my favorite of all time, and I wouldn't be able to rank the rest either!I could try but my heart would be sad at having to put some at the bottom of the list :lol:

Don't you just feel like singing and dancing along with them :P haha I do, and my sister joins me :D

"...there's a tiny little crackle on the telephone liiiiiinnneee!..."

 

I agree clocks is my favorite of all time, and I wouldn't be able to rank the rest either!I could try but my heart would be sad at having to put some at the bottom of the list :lol:

 

Yes, I do!!! I mean, it feels like they're all sat at fire, singing happy... I don't know, I think it's quite funny!

 

Isn't Clocks just perfect?! I can't, I feel like they had written it for me! <3... But yeah, I feel the same, like, I wouldn't be able to choose between some songs, I would feel kinda "guilty" for prefering one instead of another, hahaha...

IMP over A Whisper. No question.

I'm tired of In My Place, I heard it soo many times! I like A Whisper, but it isn't one of my favorite. Well, I think I prefer A Whisper.

 

About Twisted Logic... I really can't understand what the problem. Twisted Logic it's on my Coldplay Top 5 and I'm not lying!

Yes, I do!!! I mean, it feels like they're all sat at fire, singing happy... I don't know, I think it's quite funny!

 

Isn't Clocks just perfect?! I can't, I feel like they had written it for me! <3... But yeah, I feel the same, like, I wouldn't be able to choose between some songs, I would feel kinda "guilty" for prefering one instead of another, hahaha...

 

Yea, I know it puts a smile upon my face to hear them happy hanging out, having fun, and it shows they love what they do, it makes me love them even more:D

 

Yes! That's what I thought when I heard it the first time, I thought it was the most perfect song ever out there! Haha I would feel guilty too:P

About Twisted Logic... I really can't understand what the problem. Twisted Logic it's on my Coldplay Top 5 and I'm not lying!

 

There is Twisted Logic hate? For shame! It's my fave song off X&Y.

I haven't heard twisted logic in so long, but all this"talk" (:P)about it, makes me wanna listen to it

Tough... :P Both are weak(er) points of AROBTTH (that's really not saying much considering the magnificence of the album), but because In My Place (while not hated) is overrated and A Whisper is quite underrated, I'll go for A Whisper.

 

My AROBTTH;

 

1. A Rush of Blood to the Head

2. Politik

3. Clocks

4. Amsterdam

5. God Put a Smile Upon Your Face

6. The Scientist

7. Daylight

8. Warning Sign

9. In My Place

10. A Whisper

11. Green Eyes

 

Also, Twisted Logic and X & Y are both phenomenal songs. Why the hate? :confused:

IN MY PLACE IS A-FREAKIN-MAZING