X & Y vs. Mylo Xyloto

[42rock89]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall < That was a hard one

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

X&Y - 7

MX - 6

 

X&Y is my favourite Coldplay album while MX is my 2nd favourite album and the results reflect that too :P

[viva4life]

X & Y vs. Mylo Xyloto[/size]

 

 

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

GO! :D

 

1: Hurts like Heaven

2: What If

3: Charlie Brown

4: Fix You

5: Talk

6: ETIAW

7: Major Minus

8: A Message

9: Princess of China

10: The Hardest Part

11: Swallowed in the Sea

12: Don't Let it Break Your Heart

13: Up With The Birds

 

7-6 MX

[Amsterdam33]

Round 1:

MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If

 

Round 3:

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You

 

Round 5:

Can't compare the two so N/A

 

Round 6:

X & Y

 

Round 7:

Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message

 

Round 9:

Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part

 

Round 11:

Can't Compare the two so N/A

 

Round 12:

Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Up With the Birds

 

 

MX: 6

X&Y: 5

 

A lot closer then I thought it would be.

[MichMoch]

Round 1:

Square One

 

Round 2:

What If

 

Round 3:

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You

 

Round 5:

Talk

 

Round 6:

X & Y

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound

 

Round 8:

A Message

 

Round 9:

Low

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come

 

X&Y always and forever.

[Blue Nails]

Round 1:

MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

Paradise

 

Round 3:

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You

 

Round 5:

Talk

 

Round 6:

X & Y

 

Round 7:

Major Minus

 

Round 8:

U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Princess of China

 

Round 10:

Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea

 

Round 12:

Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Up With the Birds

 

Poor X&Y. I still love you. :hug:

[rafaelchampion]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

MX=8

X&Y=5

[Jdckcom]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

X&Y - 8

Mylo Xyloto - 5

 

X&Y is my personal favourite Coldplay album.

[basstialbo]

Round 1 :

MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

Paradise

 

Round 3:

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You (Sorry UATW)

 

Round 5:

Talk

 

Round 6:

X & Y

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound

 

Round 8:

U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low

 

Round 10:

Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea

 

Round 12:

Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Up With the Birds

 

MX 7

X&Y 6

 

I like MX and X&Y , are great

[rnel16]

1. HLH

2. Paradise

3. Charlie Brown

4. Fix you

5. Talk

6. ETIAW

7. Major minus

8. A message

9. Low

10. The Hardest Part

11. Swallowed in the sea

12. Dont let it break your heart

13. Honestly cant choose! Both!

 

4, 7 and 9 were also quite tricky!

 

X&Y: 6

Mylo Xyloto: 6

Tie: 1

 

Wow, I'm so surprised at this!! Mylo is hands down my fave, and IMO much better as a whole album

[DavidB5]

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

A Hopeful Transmission vs. Swallowed In The Sea

Not really fair fights

[Guest AlbaCT42!]

Round 1:

I can't!!

 

Round 2:

Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows

 

Round 4:

Fix You

Round 5:

Talk

Round 6:

Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound

 

Round 8:

U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low

 

Round 10:

Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea

 

Round 12:

Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Up With the Birds

 

X&Y: 6

MX: 6

[Cheese Nip 2]

Round 1:

MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If

 

Round 3:

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World (don't make me do this.:cry:)

 

Round 5:

Talk

 

Round 6:

X & Y

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound

 

Round 8:

A Message

 

Round 9:

Low

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come

 

Alot of these were too close. X&Y is my favorite album, but I feel horrible doing this to Mylo Xyloto....Alot of these are subject to change given my mood.

 

X&Y: 10

Mylo Xyloto: 2 (though it deserves so much more)

[Ennosuke]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

X&Y: 8 (Win !)

MX: 5

[Kenji]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Yvs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

 

X&Y - 10

Mylo Xyloto - 3

[Mrk]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven (this is hard!)

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown (this one too!)

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

[Mister MX]

Round 1: MX / Hurts Like Heaven

Round 2: What If?

Round 3: Charlie Brown

Round 4: Fix You

Round 5: Talk

Round 6: Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

Round 7: Major Minus

Round 8: U.F.O.

Round 9: Princess of China

Round 10: Tie

Round 11: Swallowed In the Sea

Round 12: Don't Let It Break Your Heart

Round 13: Til Kingdom Come

 

For MX - 7 rounds

For X & Y - 5 rounds

[joseki]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

X&Y: 8

MX: 5

[tom043]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World (No Way , I can't choose here )

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

X&Y : 11.5

MX : 1.5

 

Aw I'm sorry MX but the only ones I had difficulty choosing were round 13 and 4. But let's face it X&Y was better in a lot of ways.

[nb97]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven (0.5 to both. Both songs I didn't like at first, but both songs became to me very meaningful after some time, so I decided to say that there's draw in this round)

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown (very difficult, 0.5 to both. White Shadows has great lyrics and energy that is transferred to me. Charlie Brown is, i think, the first song from Mylo Xyloto I liked and means a lot to me.)

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World (very very difficult, but Fix You is classic and I always start crying when I hear it. Us Against The World is great song, one of my favorites from Mylo Xyloto, but as I said, Fix You is classic.)

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

X&Y : 7

MX : 6

[A Coldplay fan]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

X&Y 10

Mylo Xyloto 3

[Spider-Man]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

X&Y : 6

Mylo Xyloto : 6

[filiprasmusson]

So hard, but here's mine :)

 

Round 1:

MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

Paradise

 

Round 3:

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You

 

Round 5:

Talk

 

Round 6:

Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound

 

Round 8:

A Message

 

Round 9:

Low

 

Round 10:

Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea

 

Round 12:

Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come

[sirchampion]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown This was the hardest one

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

MX: 8 X&Y: 7

[katja]

All

X&Y;)

[Kenji]

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus :bomb:

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

 

 

MX: 3

X&Y: 10