Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Messagevs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logicvs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

MX-7

X&Y-6

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

Fix You

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

Talk

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

Princess of China (two of the worst Coldplay songs, PoC wins because of Guy's bass line)

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

The Hardest Part

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

Swallowed In The Sea

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

Up With The Birds

MX/Hurts Like Heaven

Paradise

Charlie Brown

Fix You

Talk

ETIAW

Speed Of Sound

A Message

PoC

The Hardest Part

Swallowed in the Sea

DLIBYH

Up With the Birds

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up in Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed in the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up with the Birds

 

9-4, X & Y

Round 1:

MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

Paradise

 

Round 3:

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You

 

Round 5:

Talk (that was an easy one)

 

Round 6:

Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound

 

Round 8:

U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea

 

Round 12:

Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come

 

6-7, Mylo

X&Y is much much better then MX.

MX sounds to overproduced. Sorry but thats what i think.

X&Y has better lyrics, better compositions. MX is too much BOOM BOOM BOOM.

 

Thats not the kind of Coldplay music i like. VIVA and X&Y are much cooler and better.

Pfff you cant even compare Viva and MX, they are soooooo diffrent in quallity, it's really noticable.

Round 1: MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2: Paradise

 

Round 3: White Shadows

 

Round 4: Fix You

 

Round 5: Talk

 

Round 6: X & Y

 

Round 7: Speed of Sound

 

Round 8: U.F.O.

 

Round 9: Low

 

Round 10: Up In Flames

 

Round 11: Swallowed in the Sea

 

Round 12: Twisted Logic

 

Round 13: Up With the Birds

Round 1

MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2

What If

 

Round 3

Charlie Brown

 

Round 4

Fix You

 

Round 5

Talk

 

Round 6

Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 7

Major Minus

 

Round 8

A Message

 

Round 9

Low

 

Round 10

Up In Flames

 

Round 11

Swallowed In the Sea

 

Round 12

Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13

Up With The Birds

 

X&Y - 6

MX - 7

My two favorite Coldplay's albums, 10 X&Y, 9.8 MX. Let's do this:

 

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Draw!

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Both because there are my two favorites songs!

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Hard but Speed Of Sound wins because better solo and amazing ending.

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

If PoC was without Rihanna maybe it would win.

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up in Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed in the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up with the Birds

 

9-6, X & Y :)

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall - Hardest decision ever!!! ETIAW just.

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

Conclusion = Im an X&Y fanboy!

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall - Hardest decision ever!!! ETIAW just.

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

9:4

 

I think MX could win if the arrangement changed.

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven DRAW

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames It's hard. Very close. Not too fond of either.

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

To be fair though, I've never really been a fan of MX and only recently realised how I under-appreciated the X&Y album because it's absolutely brilliant.

 

X&Y - 12

MX - 1

Round 1:

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

XY - 9

MX - 4

Square One vs. MX / Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

What If vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

White Shadows vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

Fix You vs. Us Against the World

 

Round 5:

Talk vs. M.M.I.X.

 

Round 6:

X & Y vs. Every Teardrop Is a Waterfall

 

Round 7:

Speed of Sound vs. Major Minus

 

Round 8:

A Message vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 9:

Low vs. Princess of China

 

Round 10:

The Hardest Part vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 11:

Swallowed In the Sea vs. A Hopeful Transmission; Johnny's guitar in the second half wins this one :thumbsup: Honestly, the lyrics in SitS are pretty atrocious. :thumbsdown:

 

Round 12:

Twisted Logic vs. Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 13:

Till Kingdom Come vs. Up With the Birds

 

XY - 8

MX - 5

 

Interesting comparison- imo, MX is at its strongest in the second half (excluding PoC) and X&Y is at its weakest, and vice versa. :nod: