Dont Want To Post Another Negative Thread

[Choldplayer]

But im so so so sad.The more i listen to the solo in V.H the more i cringe.Its just horrific. :-(

[TraceOddity]

I think it's 'cool' for trying to be new and different, but I don't find it 'moving', if you know what I mean. Much as I do love the song, I hope there are some classic soaring Jonny solos on the album.

 

EDIT: But we may feel differently hearing it live. Sometime things affect us differently in a live setting.

[Open-Politik]

I think its good, it goes with the song really good but it does seem as much as Johnnys guitar is loud he still seems to be limiting himself. Its like hes missing 1 finger. I still love it but Ive played it sooo much!!! The drums are great!!!Will is on top of his game!!

[BostonSportsTD]

OK IF YOU DONT WANT TO POST ANOTHER NEGATIVE THREAD WHY DID YOU MAKE THIS?!!? seriously you could have easily just written this post in the "violet hill is poor" thread. i am so fed up with this. stop trying to bring down the rest of us who happen to love this song. i'm sorry if i'm flipping up or seem rude but this thread is just so unnecesarry and all this negativity is really getting to me.

[Choldplayer]

I think it's 'cool' for trying to be new and different, but I don't find it 'moving', if you know what I mean. Much as I do love the song, I hope there are some classic soaring Jonny solos on the album.

 

 

Arghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh i love Coldplay so much,whats happening????????????????????????? :-( :-( Oh its only one song so i wont get too dissapointed.I just hear the great piano bit at the start and end then hear THAT solo and guitar and get sad.

[Open-Politik]

I think they should lock this thread!!

[Josh42]

Aww there's gotta be something you like about it...

 

And be sure you don't just hate it because it's different...I sort of had that feeling at the beginning.

[Choldplayer]

I think they should lock this thread!!

 

I agree,how i i delete this thread?

[Mister Snig]

The guitar solo is okay. While the riff is certainly no Iron Man or Smoke on the Water (in terms of how catchy it is), it definitely defines Coldplay's new style. I just wish there was more improvisation on Johnny's part. This morning I found myself singing a guitar solo! :laugh3:

[Mister Snig]

I agree,how i i delete this thread?

 

I wouldn't delete this thread. I believe this site should be a place to discuss what we like and what we don't like about Coldplay. Not a virtual church dedicated to how awesome Coldplay is (though they are awesome). Then again, I'm not an admin, so I have no say over what this site should be and what shouldn't. Just giving my two cents.

[Open-Politik]

I wouldn't delete this thread. I believe this site should be a place to discuss what we like and what we don't like about Coldplay. Not a virtual church dedicated to how awesome Coldplay is (though they are awesome).

 

No but there is sooo many. There is a thread with VH is poor. You can post in there!

[BostonSportsTD]

No but there is sooo many. There is a thread with VH is poor. You can post in there!

 

agreed. i have no problem with this person stating their opinion i was just hoping we could contain all the negativity in one thread that has already been created...'violet hill is poor' (which i'm ignoring from now on)

[TraceOddity]

Arghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh i love Coldplay so much,whats happening????????????????????????? :-( :-( Oh its only one song so i wont get too dissapointed.I just hear the great piano bit at the start and end then hear THAT solo and guitar and get sad.

 

WHat's happening is that Coldplay are trying to evolve, and it won't please everyone. But I do agree that the piano intro and outro are the best parts of the song.

 

ANd I love Chris's vocals on the outro...best part for me.

[TraceOddity]

I wouldn't delete this thread. I believe this site should be a place to discuss what we like and what we don't like about Coldplay. Not a virtual church dedicated to how awesome Coldplay is (though they are awesome). Then again, I'm not an admin, so I have no say over what this site should be and what shouldn't. Just giving my two cents.

 

Yeah, exactly. THis could have gone in the other thread, but it's a little late now, so let's discuss. I think they're awesome too, but I like the non-groupie threads where we can talk about the song and not just worship it.

[BostonSportsTD]

Yeah, exactly. THis could have gone in the other thread, but it's a little late now, so let's discuss. I think they're awesome too, but I like the non-groupie threads where we can talk about the song and not just worship it.

haha i'm not really a groupie but i really can only worship this song for now. once i am no longer in awe maybe i will be able to have an intelligent conversation about it. for now all i can say is, i don't think it is an elite coldplay song (yet) but it is very good and gives the rest of the album a lot of promise.

[BostonSportsTD]

and i think the reason this thread annoys be is because the title is "Don't Want To Post Another Negative Thred" and then this IS a negative thread... haha it's just like... if you don't want to... whyyyyd ya do it? haha

[Mister Snig]

The one thing that irked me about this song was the overuse of the synthesizer at the beginning. Sure 10-15 seconds of it is nice, but the intro lasts for about 40 seconds! And there aren't any memorable things about the intro. At least in Square One you had Johnny playing that 2001-ish (the movie, not the year) guitar riff. But this one was just 40 seconds of plain ambiance. Didn't really like that.

[BostonSportsTD]

yea i'd agree with that. it is a little too long. especially with this song being as short as it is... i hope this whole short song thing isn't a reoccuring theme on the whole album. i love their 5-6 minute songs.

[sundsbo]

haha i'm not really a groupie but i really can only worship this song for now. once i am no longer in awe maybe i will be able to have an intelligent conversation about it. for now all i can say is, i don't think it is an elite coldplay song (yet) but it is very good and gives the rest of the album a lot of promise.

 

agree! i liked it, but its not like the best coldplay song, but that wanst speed of sound eighter! but i loved this song more than speed of sound, and that was the first single to one of the greatest albums ever made!

[gus]

dammit im not a groupie i like violet hill. this is my list of coldplay songs i dont like:

 

1.-speed of sound

2.-low

3.-high speed

4.-whisper

5.-hardest part

[TraceOddity]

Agreed on the long ambient intro...it's a little too 'Eno-y',lol. It could have been shorter, or incorporated a little more musicality, imo.

 

I hope nobody took the term 'groupie' the wrong way from me considering I'm the one who started a thread last night called '*SQUEEEEEEEEEE!*':lol::lol::lol:

[RunForTheHills]

I can see why people think its too long, but this DOES sound like the album cut of the song. The long intro probably helps the album flow as a whole. I think they edited it quite nicely on BBC radio1 when they played it though.

[TraceOddity]

THat must be the official radio edit since XFM's intro was shorter too. I hate radio edits that cut music or lyrics, so this was a good call.

[Mimixxx]

Maybe the song before it ends in this way and then flows into the intro of Violet Hill.

[BostonSportsTD]

I can see why people think its too long, but this DOES sound like the album cut of the song. The long intro probably helps the album flow as a whole. I think they edited it quite nicely on BBC radio1 when they played it though.

didnt even think of that! maybe 'viva la vida' (as in the song) ends with this same synth sound that is in the beginning of violet hill. ahh i LOVE when songs flow into eachother...coldplay has never really done this!