May 25, 201214 yr Clocks 25 Death And All His Friends 11 Politik 24 Shiver 15 Violet Hill 20 Something must have gone wrong here. Just counting the changes, Clocks, DAAHF, Politik, and Shiver are incorrect. Saw Clocks go from 25 to 24 when he added it. :O Clocks 29 Death And All His Friends 9 Politik 26 Shiver 13 Violet Hill 20
May 25, 201214 yr Waiiiiiiit, I'm confused. What are you talking about with Clocks? And which count are we going with?
May 25, 201214 yr ^^ Good catch, the numbers were thrown off because there were subtractions where some posters highlighted yellow, and vice versa Remember!: Yellow is +1, Red is -1 Going off the corrected numbers (thx laxwatcher) Clocks 30 Death And All His Friends 8 Politik 27 Shiver 12 Violet Hill 21
May 25, 201214 yr You should edit your Violet Hill to 20. ^ I forgot to add my subtraction to the points.
May 25, 201214 yr I feel like the numbers should add up to a multiple of 10, though, since the original post gave 10 points to each song, and the points should go nowhere, except for that time when we subtracted 20 from each song, which shouldn't change the multiple of 10 rule. Clocks 30 Death And All His Friends 8 Politik 27 Shiver 12 Violet Hill 21 If Violet Hill is changed to 20 (I'm going to trust laxwatcher for now), I think it adds up to 67, which obviously isn't a multiple of 10....
May 25, 201214 yr Wait - I come to different numbers - as I see it they should be: Clocks 29 Death And All His Friends 10 Politik 25 Shiver 14 Violet Hill 20 Explanation: first confusion starts when Dee only took off/gave 2 points instead of 4. But as we cannot just guess 2 points we have to stick with it. Then musicalfrogs made a mistake by reducing clocks to 25 instead of raising it to 27 as I guess from the colours his intentions were. Disregarding the colour confusion (tomson used green for minus and red for plus) all other substractions and additions are correct as far as I can see, so it's only just clocks that has to be amended. Unless somebody has edited their post without telling of course. Please look over that agin and if you agree with me, this is my change then: Clocks 28 Death And All His Friends 11 Politik 24 Shiver 14 Violet Hill 21
May 25, 201214 yr Wait - I come to different numbers - as I see it they should be: Clocks 29 Death And All His Friends 10 Politik 25 Shiver 14 Violet Hill 20 Explanation: first confusion starts when Dee only took off/gave 2 points instead of 4. But as we cannot just guess 2 points we have to stick with it. Then musicalfrogs made a mistake by reducing clocks to 25 instead of raising it to 27 as I guess from the colours his intentions were. Disregarding the colour confusion (tomson used green for minus and red for plus) all other substractions and additions are correct as far as I can see, so it's only just clocks that has to be amended. Unless somebody has edited their post without telling of course. Please look over that agin and if you agree with me, this is my change then: Clocks 28 Death And All His Friends 11 Politik 24 Shiver 14 Violet Hill 21 Sorry, I'm somewhat of a grammar freak... Well, not really grammar, but please call me musicalfrogbricks (or MFB, for short). Also, it's she, not he. ;) OK, so that would mean that the total would be.... 98.... I suppose that's close enough. Are we going to continue now?
May 25, 201214 yr Sorry, I'm somewhat of a grammar freak... Well, not really grammar, but please call me musicalfrogbricks (or MFB, for short). Also, it's she, not he. ;) Sorry, musicalfrogbricks! OK, so that would mean that the total would be.... 98.... I suppose that's close enough. And with the 2 missing points from Dee we are back to 100, right? Are we going to continue now? Let's wait what the others say.
May 25, 201214 yr What has happened here? :o This whole thread seems to have dissolved into confusion :laugh3:
May 25, 201214 yr I really don't know how it could stay a multiple of 10. I've been on this thread for pretty long, and there have been people who have only added, or added 1 and subtracted 1. So it's not the same every time. Additionally, we reduced everything by 20, 30 and even 40 when a song was eliminated to make it easier to finish the game. I don't think we can just go off of what we started at the beginning. I just added each of the green/yellow ones and subtracted all of the red, which gave me those values.
May 25, 201214 yr Here's my thought process. This is Dee's post one page back: Clocks 25, Clocks 26 (phantoneku adds), Clocks 27 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Clocks 28 (tomson101 adds), Clocks 29 (musicalfrogbricks adds) Death And All His Friends 13, DAAHF 12 (phantoneku subtracts), DAAHF 11 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), DAAHF 10 (tomson101 subtracts), DAAHF 9 (Raphaele subtracts), DAAHF 10 (laxwatcher adds) Politik 22, Politik 23 (phantoneku adds), Politik 24 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Politik 25 (tomson101 adds), Politik 24 (Raphaele subtracts), Politik 25 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Politik 26 (laxwatcher adds) Shiver 17, Shiver 16 (phantoneku subtracts), Shiver 15 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), Shiver 14 (tomson101 subtracts), Shiver 15 (Raphaele adds), Shiver 14 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), Shiver 13 (laxwatcher subtracts) Violet Hill 20, Violet Hill 21 (Raphaele adds), Violet Hill 20 (laxwatcher subtracts) So finally: Clocks 29 Death And All His Friends 10 Politik 26 Shiver 13 Violet Hill 20 Now to add Danceteacher's changes: Clocks 28 Death And All His Friends 11 Politik 25 Shiver 13 Violet Hill 21 Those are the final numbers ^ (hope you guys agree) Makes sense?
May 25, 201214 yr I really don't know how it could stay a multiple of 10. I've been on this thread for pretty long, and there have been people who have only added, or added 1 and subtracted 1. So it's not the same every time. Additionally, we reduced everything by 20, 30 and even 40 when a song was eliminated to make it easier to finish the game. I don't think we can just go off of what we started at the beginning. I agree - don't have a clue what the numbers should add up to. I just added each of the green/yellow ones and subtracted all of the red, which gave me those values. That is the problem! Tomsom 101 used the wrong colours, he marked the ones he was substracting from in green and the ones he was adding to in red. So my thought process is this: This is Dee's post one page back: Clocks 25, Clocks 26 (phantoneku adds), Clocks 27 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Clocks 26 (tomson101 substracts), Clocks 27 (musicalfrogbricks adds) Death And All His Friends 13, DAAHF 12 (phantoneku subtracts), DAAHF 11 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), DAAHF 12 (tomson101 adds), DAAHF 10 (Raphaele subtracts), DAAHF 11 (laxwatcher adds) Politik 22, Politik 23 (phantoneku adds), Politik 24 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Politik 23 (tomson101 substracts), Politik 22 (Raphaele subtracts), Politik 23 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Politik 24 (laxwatcher adds) Shiver 17, Shiver 16 (phantoneku subtracts), Shiver 15 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), Shiver 16 (tomson101 adds), Shiver 17 (Raphaele adds), Shiver 16 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), Shiver 15 (laxwatcher subtracts) Violet Hill 20, Violet Hill 21 (Raphaele adds), Violet Hill 20 (laxwatcher subtracts) So the numbers after laxwatchers post: Clocks 27 Death And All His Friends 11 Politik 24 Shiver 15 Violet Hill 20 So then phantoneku makes confusion complete by adding a point to Violet Hill from nowhere. Ignoring that rogue point after phantoneku's post it should be: Clocks 28 Death And All His Friends 10 Politik 25 Shiver 14 Violet Hill 20 My changes added: Clocks 27 Death And All His Friends 11 Politik 24 Shiver 14 Violet Hill 21 Wow, the amount of time I have now spent on this crazy ;) Does everyone agree now?:inquisitive:
May 25, 201214 yr So just read this over one more time. This is Dee's post one page back: Clocks 25, Clocks 26 (phantoneku adds), Clocks 27 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Clocks 26 (tomson101 substracts even though he put green), Clocks 27 (musicalfrogbricks adds) Clocks 28 (phantoneku adds), Clocks 27 (Danceteacher subtracts) Death And All His Friends 13, DAAHF 12 (phantoneku subtracts), DAAHF 11 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), DAAHF 12 (tomson101 adds even though he put red), DAAHF 11 (Raphaele subtracts), DAAHF 10 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), DAAHF 11 (laxwatcher adds) DAAHF 10 (phantoneku subtracts) DAAHF 11 (Danceteacher adds) Politik 22, Politik 23 (phantoneku adds), Politik 24 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Politik 23 (tomson101 subtracts even though he put green), Politik 22 (Raphaele subtracts), Politik 23 (musicalfrogbricks adds), Politik 24 (laxwatcher adds) Politik 25 (phantoneku adds) Politik 24 (Danceteacher subtracts) Shiver 17, Shiver 16 (phantoneku subtracts), Shiver 15 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), Shiver 16 (tomson101 adds even though he put red), Shiver 17 (Raphaele adds), Shiver 16 (musicalfrogbricks subtracts), Shiver 15 (laxwatcher subtracts) Shiver 14 (phantoneku subtracts) Violet Hill 20, Violet Hill 21 (Raphaele adds), Violet Hill 20 (laxwatcher subtracts) Violet Hill 21 (Danceteacher adds) So the numbers after everybody is added: Clocks 27 Death And All His Friends 11 Politik 24 Shiver 14 Violet Hill 21
May 25, 201214 yr I hate to add to the confusion, but back on page 5, 1.36 was deleted even though it had 10 points. Is it worth adding it back in? Or shall we just wait until the 'next round'?
Create an account or sign in to comment