August 23, 201114 yr Author Thank you. And this is a good point. [: If everyone felt the same way about bands/albums/songs it would be extremely boring and really weird at the same time. Coldplayer 1: I like Coldplay. Coldplayer 2: Me too! Coldplayer 3: I hope they go on tour soon. Coldplayer 2: me too! Coldplayer 3: the new album is going to be good. Coldplayer 1: yes. :blank:
August 23, 201114 yr Coldplayer 1: I like Coldplay. Coldplayer 2: Me too! Coldplayer 3: I hope they go on tour soon. Coldplayer 2: me too! Coldplayer 3: the new album is going to be good. Coldplayer 1: yes. :blank: I get the gist of what you're saying. But a lot of people feel differently about the albums. Which is the their favorite. Which is their favorite song. Some hate ETIAW. Some love it. Some think their new songs are among their best. Some say they're the worst. Some people prefer Parachutes/ARoBttH and some like VlVoDaAHF/Mylo Xyloto better. We all like the band. But to varying degrees. And we have individual opinions of ever era. Every album. Every song.
August 23, 201114 yr Author Well it was just an example of what it would be like if we all agreed on everything. So I agree! I should have indicated that. :lol:
August 23, 201114 yr Those scores suck. I love all their new songs and their old ones. But these new songs deserve better than that. The boys have been putting everything into these songs. Rolling stones got it all wrong. HLH, MM, UATW, CB, and ETIAW all deserve 5/5 or even 6/5.
August 23, 201114 yr The Critics are Profesionals so when they give a 2,5/5 or 3/5 its pretty good. They only give 5/5 when they hear an absolutly Perfect Song like "Imagine" from "John Lennon" would get 5/5 probably or "Stairway to Heaven" from "Led Zeppelin". I think its a pretty fair and good score although it looks Avarage for us but thats obvious the most Coldplay Fans here arent proud of that and would rather give 5,5/5. The only thing i dont agree with them is "Charlie Brown" that should have more than "Us against the World".
August 24, 201114 yr Does anybody know if they have reviewed Moving to Mars and Major Minus too, in another edition?
August 24, 201114 yr Author I don't believe they have. They did rate the song ETIAW at 3.5 stars though. But I've never seen anything in there about the EP.
August 25, 201114 yr idg how CB is only 2.5. but i like that UATW got a good score...it's probably my fav out of the stuff they've played so far....
August 29, 201114 yr Who cares what critics say really... All that matters is what we think. XD I don't usually do this but... + ∞
August 30, 201114 yr Who cares what rolling stone thinks. That's the real point. They are notoriously biased.
Create an account or sign in to comment