sounds rather mellow to me on the album... the live version has more passion to it... it's kinda weak , the studio version... where the hell is JB? I can barely hear him! And the verses seem kinda to be really low on the richness.. I don't know, to me, the production killed the song, and I was afraid of it ,given how perfect it sounds live and how wonderful the song itself is...

I honestly prefer the studio recording houndred times more than the live one. Live I didn't mention it too much, it was a good song, nothing more. Now, with this masterpiece of production its more, clearly more for me!

both versions are great, so 8/10!

8

Live it's a 10. Studio-Version 9.

 

Sadly they missed to include the epic "light a fire....." choir in the studio version.

I cant stand the beginning of the song it sounds Exactly like alvin the chipmunk.

Absolutely LOVE it! 10/10.

8 live for me is better and thats a 10/10

best song ever 10!

A solid 8 :awesome:

Me too

Cause of Chris' singing beeing slightly slower than the live version. Its weird. It was overproduced, as many of the songs.

10! I love this song both live (esp from Glastonbury) AND the studio version. This could be one of my all-time favorite Coldplay songs!

9, I don't know why, but the live version sounded slightly better than the studio version. :nod:

This song is absolutely amazing. No more to say.

I love how in some parts of the verses there is nothing else than Chris, his guitar, the piano and the beat. Sounds so intimate. :wacky:

10. A couple minor things I would change, but it's still absolutely one of the most head-bang-iest yet melodic songs ever. I love it. So epic.

I rly love this song. It's amazing ! For me the best song of MX.

 

Ps. Hi everyone ! :)

Voted a 9 because I like the live version more ;)

10/10

 

Beautiful song for sure.

I gave it 9. I can't stand the 'COLDPLAY IS PERFECT IN EVERYTHING THEY DO ALL THE TIME, 10/10, 100/100' fans. :rolleyes:

I gave it a 10/10 although I do think I prefer the LIVE version better.;)

10. It's perfect. It's definitely the highlight of the album.