When you have heard the studio version, rate the song...

10/10

I haven't listened to it enough times to develop an opinion, but it's damn good. :P

10. I was afraid it wasn't going to sound big enough, but i think its good.

My goodness. It's lushly more intimate on record than it is live but that outro is just beautiful. It just binds the whole song together. A stunning success. It's definitely the first 10 I've given to Coldplay in a long time.

5.

 

Just an instant (no doubt over)reaction to what struck me as an unnecessarily over-produced version of a song that was quite simply perfect as it was.

 

If you don't want knee-jerk reactions don't post knee-jerk polls :P

A solid 8 :awesome:

I thought the "light a fire" part would be more epic and louder but it wasn't. Kinda disappointed about that but it's still very good. I'd give it an 8.

9, my second fave from the album! :D

10.

And the Ending wow it nearly makes me cry.

10. This is their best song since Politik. Nothing more to be said.

10.

It let me kinda spechless. Just... love it.

I thought the "light a fire" part would be more epic and louder but it wasn't.

 

This!!! But i still liked it A LOT :) one of the best songs they have released in a long time...

10/10. Pure awesome song!

A solid 8 :awesome:

 

same here. Live version it's way more epic

The best new addition to the song are the violins that come in right before the end when Chris is coming in with "So weeee saaaaawwww" it adds this awesome little layer.

i love this song :)

Meant nothing to me,i give it an 1.

Stunning ending which made me tear up. Gave it an 8 for now.

absolutely awesome! It's like the live version but then even better! Really amazing. What a song --> 10/10!:D

its my favorite song in all times :) so 10!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

10 from me. It's my favorite track off MX. I can't get it out of my head! I love it!!! I've been walking around my house humming it so much that my kids have picked up on it and now they are humming it, too!

great song + awesome ending :thumbsup:

8, I can't give it a 10 considering that the live version is way better, I was expecting more.

10. it's got to be the best song on the album- today I was listening to it on my iPod, and I turned to my friend and said "if they release this as a single, it'll win a Grammy" :P

 

the piano ending is brilliant, who knew that it was part of the song when we heard it live?! the guitar, Chris' vocals, even the lyrics... I'd say that it's their best song, and best-executed song, since Clocks.