AROBTTH vs. Mylo Xyloto

[Coeurli]

I do love MX (songs like UATW, UWTB or HLH are definitely among my favourite Coldplay songs for instance), but I think AROBTTH wins on every song. It is simply too epic, imo.

[joseki]

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds

 

 

 

9-2 :laugh3:

 

Round 8 was the easiest one, round 3 and 11 was the hardest two.

[Kingzilla]

1. Poltik - the most epic Coldplay song ever

2. In my place - It's close, but YEAHHHH HOW LONG MUST YOU WAIT FOR HIM is better then PARA PARA PARADISE

3. GPASUYF - I hate Charlie brown with a passion, and I love GPASUYF with passion.

4. Clocks - Closest thing Coldplay has gotten to perfection... Scratch that, it is PERFECTION.

5. Major Minus - I love the guitar and I've listened to daylight too much so yeah...

6. Green Eyes - I dont like UFO and Green Eyes is fun to sing too.

7. Warning sign - Because PoC is barely a Coldplay song

8. Up in flames - mostly because I dont like A Whisper.

9. A rush of blood to the head - Such an epic song.

10. Amsterdam - Probably one of the best songs ever.

11. The scientist (I missed it) - Because the song is so emotional and I can play it on the piano.

 

9 - 2 AROBTTH

[Keronte]

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise... tough one

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames, i hate both...

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds

[smallnshort247]

Rush of blood wins all of them for me as well. MX isn't bad but AROBTTH is probably my favorite album, and then Parachutes after that.

 

With that said, I think the MX tour was the best live performance from the 3 yours I've been to (X&Y Viva and MX)

[Coldplayer_42_arobtth]

Definitely AROBTTH.

Mylo xyloto is still amazing though!

[nvdmm]

this is a pointless debate. its like asking which is better: the aventador or a 2CV?

 

reading through the first couple of pages on here was pretty depressing actually!

[Sam1036]

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds

 

 

7-4

 

Song nine was quite weak on both albums. Easily my least favourite song on both albums, I love MX but AROBTTH is my favourite of the five.

[Revolverwin]

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyesvs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds

 

AROBTTH-5

MX-6

[WarningSign42]

MX/Hurts Like Heaven

Paradise

GPASUYF

The Scientist

Clocks

Major Minus

Green Eyes

Warning Sign (Best song on AROBTTH in my opinion)

Up in Flames

DLIBYH

Amsterdam

[Texas Rez]

Round 1:

Politik vs. Mylo Xyloto/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

God Put a Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up in Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush of Blood to the Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up with the Birds

 

6-5, making A Rush of Blood to the Head the winner for me! :dance:

[lorepalma]

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. Mylo Xyloto

 

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise (this was hard)

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown (GPASUYF is a masterpiece!)

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds