I do love MX (songs like UATW, UWTB or HLH are definitely among my favourite Coldplay songs for instance), but I think AROBTTH wins on every song. It is simply too epic, imo.

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds

 

 

 

9-2 :laugh3:

 

Round 8 was the easiest one, round 3 and 11 was the hardest two.

1. Poltik - the most epic Coldplay song ever

2. In my place - It's close, but YEAHHHH HOW LONG MUST YOU WAIT FOR HIM is better then PARA PARA PARADISE

3. GPASUYF - I hate Charlie brown with a passion, and I love GPASUYF with passion.

4. Clocks - Closest thing Coldplay has gotten to perfection... Scratch that, it is PERFECTION.

5. Major Minus - I love the guitar and I've listened to daylight too much so yeah...

6. Green Eyes - I dont like UFO and Green Eyes is fun to sing too.

7. Warning sign - Because PoC is barely a Coldplay song

8. Up in flames - mostly because I dont like A Whisper.

9. A rush of blood to the head - Such an epic song.

10. Amsterdam - Probably one of the best songs ever.

11. The scientist (I missed it) - Because the song is so emotional and I can play it on the piano.

 

9 - 2 AROBTTH

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise... tough one

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames, i hate both...

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds

Rush of blood wins all of them for me as well. MX isn't bad but AROBTTH is probably my favorite album, and then Parachutes after that.

 

With that said, I think the MX tour was the best live performance from the 3 yours I've been to (X&Y Viva and MX)

Definitely AROBTTH.

Mylo xyloto is still amazing though!

this is a pointless debate. its like asking which is better: the aventador or a 2CV?

 

reading through the first couple of pages on here was pretty depressing actually!

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds

 

 

7-4

 

Song nine was quite weak on both albums. Easily my least favourite song on both albums, I love MX but AROBTTH is my favourite of the five.

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyesvs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds

 

AROBTTH-5

MX-6

MX/Hurts Like Heaven

Paradise

GPASUYF

The Scientist

Clocks

Major Minus

Green Eyes

Warning Sign (Best song on AROBTTH in my opinion)

Up in Flames

DLIBYH

Amsterdam

Round 1:

Politik vs. Mylo Xyloto/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise

 

Round 3:

God Put a Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up in Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush of Blood to the Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up with the Birds

 

6-5, making A Rush of Blood to the Head the winner for me! :dance:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. Mylo Xyloto

 

Round 1:

Politik vs. MX/Hurts Like Heaven

 

Round 2:

In My Place vs. Paradise (this was hard)

 

Round 3:

God Put A Smile Upon Your Face vs. Charlie Brown (GPASUYF is a masterpiece!)

 

Round 4:

The Scientist vs. Us Against The World

 

Round 5:

Clocks vs. M.M.I.X./Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall

 

Round 6:

Daylight vs. Major Minus

 

Round 7:

Green Eyes vs. U.F.O.

 

Round 8:

Warning Sign vs. Princess Of China

 

Round 9:

A Whisper vs. Up In Flames

 

Round 10:

A Rush Of Blood To The Head vs. A Hopeful Transmission/Don't Let It Break Your Heart

 

Round 11:

Amsterdam vs. Up With The Birds