I just discovered a review of the single "Fix You".. It's by a critic from Wessex, called "JS" - you can find it here: http://www.wessexscene.co.uk/article.php?sid=1164. I was kind of pissed when I read it..

 

This guy says that Fix You is "predictable, entirely unoriginal and mind-numbingly boring".. :confused: Below, you can also see a review of the Kaiser Chiefs - this reviewer seems to hate this particular style of music in general! :angry:

^oh! i just read it!!!

 

 

"Either the Coldplay boys completely lack perspective, or they really know their target audience. ‘Fix You’ may be ‘anthemic’, ‘emotional’, ‘life-affirming’, ‘inspired’ and ‘sensitive’. However it’s also predictable, entirely unoriginal and mind-numbingly boring"

 

 

ehh.....is it just me or that doesnt make sense.. :confused:

:dizzy2:

 

This guy may not love "fix you", but I this his critic is very needlessly agressive !!

I ain't even gonna read it.

:lol: ^ you have the right idea and i will do the same ... reviews like that are from people who do not know what they are talking about .... :rolleyes:

I think its about right ;) , glad to see I'm not the only one.

Ohhh well. I don't care what the critics say personally.

I wont bother reading it either.

Pfft, some of these critics just don't know the meaning of music. The Kaiser Chiefs review was emphasized a LOT (Sorry if I spelt that wrong by the way :rolleyes:) compared to the Fix You review. God, when will these critics ever quit? :rolleyes:

he has a point saying it's contrived though :idea2:

*awaits stoning*

*picks up stone*

 

*sharpens it*

 

*uses it write name on the road*

 

I agree Charlie, it's a good song, but it is contrived

Actually it's a very bad review - no cases, theses only.

Funny is the fact, that the guy is talking halfway through the pretty short review about other bands - it sounds, that his intention was to mention his favourite bands, not to critizise fix you :-)

However, I don't care about reviews... I have my own opinion, I guess...

to each his own.

But that's one bad review to hundreds of good ones, I wouldn't worry with this ;)

Who cares what the review says? Still a great song, right.

well...Fix You isn't the most original song by Coldplay and not my fave, but it deserves more than 0 points out of 5...

Who cares what the review says? Still a great song' date=' right.[/quote']

 

definitely! ;)

Pshh.

 

The reviewer lacks a brain.

its so true :nice:

*picks up stone*

 

*sharpens it*

 

*uses it write name on the road*

 

I agree Charlie, it's a good song, but it is contrived

 

 

:lol: *phew*

i wasn't up for being pelted with a sharp stone! :P

I ain't even gonna read it.

 

same here...

ouch,i don't like that reviewer...... :angry: