PoC sounds exactly the same in this supposedly "promo" leak than on itunes official stream. just sayin

 

Probably, but I don't think I read any legitimate issues about PoC.

theyre the same radio and leakversion :(

are we talking the same language? im here to stay, friend. secondly, where did i post i thought it was the real version? ive posted maybe 4 or 5 times on this thread. ive never once uttered that it was the real version, and even if i did, i sure as hell didnt say "this is the real version, and anyone who says differently is in denial". thats the difference between me and you and alot of other people on here. Its the matter of fact, holier than thou attitude of "i know this is the real version because....well, because i now its the real version", or conversely the "i know this is the fake version, promo version, because....well because i just know it is". No one knows, and anyone on here, who isnt connected with the band, is lying flat out.

 

EMI's word shouldnt be considered final. Record labels, all record labels, view illegal filesharing as tantamount to treason, punishable by large fines or even jail time. They have a stake in trying to have people buy the record and discourage illegal filesharing.

 

Ive never once on here said that this was the final version or that it was a promo. so i;d suggest you reread my posts, and take a second look. Its silly to debate with people who make up statements. Im happy to defend my posts, but how can i defend a post i never made? Thats dumb and pointless.

 

The main point of it is, lets have a debate about the leak being final or not. Thats a good idea. But lets not kid ourselves that we can deduce whether its final or not, and lets not debase ourselves by acting like we are in the know about whether its the final version or not. Opinions are fine, but acting like holier than thou folks who are in the know, when they really aren't... take that elsewhere

 

Firstly, "alot" is two words...so it is "a lot." Secondly, I never said it WAS. I'm saying, based on what I read for the Espanol Coldplay Facebook, and what the fans have reported about the tracks, and the fact that this happened to Dave Matthew's Band, I believe it is POSSIBLE that this is not the true version.

theyre the same radio and leakversion :(

 

Really? Oh crap. Goodbye good expectations, then.

So....when will have the real version?? What will be tomorrow track??

theyre the same radio and leakversion :(

 

 

so if they are the same, i dont understand how BBC would be playing a record thats in promo form. these guys get advance copies of albums. they would know if it was a promo or not. or unfinished or not. why would they play, during an interview with the band, a version of the album that is not final? makes no sense. I would assume BBC gets final finished albums. what band would send out unfinished albums that differ from the real album to the press?

 

im not questioning or doubting you m.rogo86, im just posing a question for others to answer.

It is the final version , and it is supreme

so if they are the same, i dont understand how BBC would be playing a record thats in promo form. these guys get advance copies of albums. they would know if it was a promo or not. or unfinished or not. why would they play, during an interview with the band, a version of the album that is not final? makes no sense. I would assume BBC gets final finished albums. what band would send out unfinished albums that differ from the real album to the press?

 

im not questioning or doubting you m.rogo86, im just posing a question for others to answer.

 

Perhaps the interview was recorded in September? Perhaps after, Chris woke up one day and said "wait, no, HLH isn't finished...and then went and finished it."

The interview was live.

I wanna kill the guy that invented the auto-tune. Anyone wants to join me?

The interview was live.

 

reportedly, live at the time lol

Firstly, "alot" is two words...so it is "a lot." Secondly, I never said it WAS. I'm saying, based on what I read for the Espanol Coldplay Facebook, and what the fans have reported about the tracks, and the fact that this happened to Dave Matthew's Band, I believe it is POSSIBLE that this is not the true version.

 

 

 

no you didnt. i read your post, something you didnt do with my post. You said

 

"No, it is not the one in the shop. It is a promtional copy of the album a.k.a. unfinished version."

 

and

 

"I thought it was just me, but looking here confirms it. We do not have the final version of the album......."

 

those are quotes directly from you. Those are many things but they aren't "I believe it is possible" statements. Those are, I know better than everyone here that this is the promo version.

 

Secondly you stated, "based on what i read for the Espanol Coldplay site", since you are so keen with grammar i would have thought you'd have caught this little gem. I always thought the proper way of typing that would be "based on what i read from/on/at the Espanol Coldplay site".

 

So we learned two things, you DID SAY IT WAS, and second, those in glass houses...well you know the rest

I wanna kill the guy that invented the auto-tune. Anyone wants to join me?

ME. It's the one thing in music that I hate more than anything else in music, closely followed by anything that uses it on every damn song.

I think the interview was recorded last week, I read that on twitter.

I don't think it's the final mix. Wasn't Hurts Like Heaven supposed to fade into Paradise without silence? Or did I misinterpret?

I actually dig the background auto-tune vocals. It works for the song.

I wanna kill the guy that invented the auto-tune. Anyone wants to join me?

 

They don't use auto-tune here. They use voice effect (HLH, MM, UIF a little) but no auto-tune. Why don't you kill that guy instead?

Yeah I doubt it. i think this is definitely the final version. I think they are just saying that because they want to persuade many with the leak to buy the album even though they already have it. Even though many of us Coldplayers will buy the album anyways, but some people are happy they got the leak already that they probably won't buy it.

Perhaps the interview was recorded in September? Perhaps after, Chris woke up one day and said "wait, no, HLH isn't finished...and then went and finished it."

 

 

what evidence is there of this? does zane tape/record interviews and then air them a month later? were promo copies even out a month ago? Why september? why not June or July? Or live for that manner?

 

Lets posit facts here. theorizing is cool, but it only goes so far without proof or things to back it up with. If Zane or the BBC has a history of taping segments and releasing them later on in the future, then thats fine. but if there is no history of that, then we are back at square one.

no you didnt. i read your post, something you didnt do with my post. You said

 

"No, it is not the one in the shop. It is a promtional copy of the album a.k.a. unfinished version."

 

and

 

"I thought it was just me, but looking here confirms it. We do not have the final version of the album......."

 

those are quotes directly from you. Those are many things but they aren't "I believe it is possible" statements. Those are, I know better than everyone here that this is the promo version.

 

Secondly you stated, "based on what i read for the Espanol Coldplay site", since you are so keen with grammar i would have thought you'd have caught this little gem. I always thought the proper way of typing that would be "based on what i read from/on/at the Espanol Coldplay site".

 

So we learned two things, you DID SAY IT WAS, and second, those in glass houses...well you know the rest

 

LOL, I absolutely DID NOT say it was a.k.a. unfinished copy....I don't even use the words a.k.a, stop making stuff up ;)

:confused:

I think the interview was recorded last week, I read that on twitter.

 

 

recorded last week, isnt recorded in september. why are some people suggesting september. who's twitter was this on? zanes? bbc's?

Are we going to get HLH tonight? If so, we'll see if it's the final version or not.

what evidence is there of this? does zane tape/record interviews and then air them a month later? were promo copies even out a month ago? Why september? why not June or July? Or live for that manner?

 

Lets posit facts here. theorizing is cool, but it only goes so far without proof or things to back it up with. If Zane or the BBC has a history of taping segments and releasing them later on in the future, then thats fine. but if there is no history of that, then we are back at square one.

 

The word "perhaps" indicates a theory....nowhere did I posit a fact lol, you guys...too funny!

They don't use auto-tune here. They use voice effect (HLH, MM, UIF a little) but no auto-tune. Why don't you kill that guy instead?

 

I thought it was auto-tune. At least in HLH, but I guess I was wrong. I hate auto-tune anyway, so, that's not going to change anything... I'm gonna kill him/her.

 

:saw:

ME. It's the one thing in music that I hate more than anything else in music, closely followed by anything that uses it on every damn song.

 

Great, now we're two in this.