Noel Gallagher

Gerard Way

Dan Reynolds

Brandon Flowers

Brandon Flowers

Are we supposed to be judging these as musicians or songwriters or singers? Noel Gallagher is an average musician but a stunning songwriter. Florence Welsch is an average songwriter but an amazing singer.

Just curious :)

 

Jonsi, Ian Brown and Ashcroft should be there IMO.

Jonsi, Ian Brown and Ashcroft should be there IMO.

I agree

 

 

One day we could do the same topic but for female artists (in this case there's only Florence)

My trouble with this game is that I don't know half of those frontmen at all...

My trouble with this game is that I don't know half of those frontmen at all...

 

Yeah ill vote when it gets down to Chris, Thom Yorke, Bono, John Lennon, and Tom Chaplin

Are we supposed to be judging these as musicians or songwriters or singers? Noel Gallagher is an average musician but a stunning songwriter. Florence Welsch is an average songwriter but an amazing singer.

Just curious :)

 

Jonsi, Ian Brown and Ashcroft should be there IMO.

 

This is mainly a thread for which frontmen you prefer. You can judge them either songwriting or singing or both, it's up to you;)

 

And before this thread is a ghost town when AHFOD news gets more and more news:DI shall add Richard Ashcroft, Ian Brown and Jonsi. These are the last ones I'm adding:P

Round is over!

 

Brandon Flowers 2

Gerard Way 2

 

Another tie-breaker? Vote for the one you want to eliminate from above!

 

The results will be revealed later.

Gerard Way

Gerard Way 3

Brandon Flowers 2

 

Gerard Way has joined 'The Black Parade' and left the game.

 

The survivors:

 

Chris Martin (Starfish,Pectoralz,Nappies)

Thom Yorke (Radiohead, AFP)

Matt Bellamy (Muse)

Kelly Jones (Stereophonics)

Alex Turner (AM)

Ricky Wilson (Kaiser Chiefs)

Brandon Flowers (The Killers)

Dave Grohl (Foo Fighters)

John Lennon (The Beatles)

Kurt Cobain (Nirvana)

Jonsi (Sigur Ros)

Richard Ashcroft (The Verve)

Ian Brown (Stone Roses)

Chris Cornell (Soundgarden)

Zach De La Rocha (RATM)

Pete Doherty (Libertines)

Celeb Followill (Kings Of Leon)

Bono (U2)

Tom Chaplin (Keane)

Damon Albarn (Blur)

Fran Healy (Travis)

Florence Welsh (Florence & The Machine)

Dan Reynolds (Imagine Dragons)

Noel Gallagher (Oasis)

 

I vote for Dan Reynolds, again. :P

I just googled Dan Reynolds, he is from ImagineDragons ? I don't like Imagine Dragons, don't like that voice, so I'm voting for Dan Reynolds then....

meh me too Dan Reynolds

Dan Reynolds

 

P.s. a suggestion: write the name of the band near the name of the frontman to make it easier to choose.

Dan Reynolds

 

P.s. a suggestion: write the name of the band near the name of the frontman to make it easier to choose.

 

Done:P

Dan Reynolds

 

PS. Thom Yorke is also in Atoms For Peace ;)

and psst, typo, it's Pectoralz ;)

Dan Reynolds

 

He's a good lyricist but as a singer he's just average to me. I like his band as a whole more than him.

 

Unless you don't want to make the list too long, you should add Paul McCartney and Eddie Vedder.

and psst, typo, it's Pectoralz ;)

 

Oops:laugh3:

Dan Reynolds.

Round is over!

 

Dan Reynolds 6

 

Literally no one voted for anyone but Dan that time and he is gone. The 'Demons' have took him away.

 

The survivors who live to fight another day

 

Chris Martin (The 'AROBTTH' band)

Thom Yorke (Radiohead, AFP)

Matt Bellamy (Muse)

Kelly Jones (Stereophonics)

Jonsi (Sigur Ros)

Richard Ashcroft (The Verve)

Ian Brown (Stone Roses)

Alex Turner (AM)

Ricky Wilson (Kaiser Chiefs)

Brandon Flowers (The Killers)

Dave Grohl (Foo Fighters, drummer for Nirvana)

John Lennon (The Beatles)

Kurt Cobain (Nirvana)

Chris Cornell (Soundgarden)

Zach De La Rocha (RATM)

Pete Doherty (Libertines)

Celeb Followill (Kings Of Leon)

Bono (U2)

Tom Chaplin (Keane)

Damon Albarn (Blur, Gorillaz)

Fran Healy (Travis)

Florence Welsh (Florence & The Machine)

Noel Gallagher (Oasis, High Flying Birds)

 

This time I'll go...erm...this is hard...I'll tell you what. I'll vote next round:)

Pete Doherty

Matt Bellamy