Please vote out of 10!

 

(Don't forget you can only vote once... make sure you're sure of your answer before scoring!)

 

STUDIO:

 

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1O9X0_WNTY]YouTube - ‪Coldplay - Major Minus (Official)‬‏[/ame]

 

LIVE:

 

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79ojmqJFfR0]YouTube - ‪Coldplay - " Major Minus " HQ Live @ Rock am Ring festival : Nürburgring, Germany‬‏[/ame]

Ill listen to it more times

 

 

But hugely dissapointed about what they did to Chris Martin´s voice,

Its probably Will singing on the back.

 

Live version > this version

 

On the other hand,

 

Studio version sounds more powerfull,and the "UHH" is better than live.

sorry double post

 

Coldplaying crashed

 

 

 

Ditto

^True. The live version was giving a hope, but this distorted computer voice - what for, Chris? Jeez.

Hmmm. I actually like the production on Chris's voice for once. It ain't just a lazy overdubbing like some other Coldplay tracks. It's different I'll give them that and I liked it...a lot! A song that will definitely need to blast through my stereos to wake up the neighbourhood.

 

8/10

I dont know WTF has happened to me,but the song dont "fill" me,and i liked it from the first moment

 

But i give it a 9 because is the best song for now :\

^True. The live version was giving a hope, but this distorted computer voice - what for, Chris? Jeez.

 

Surely this is the work of Brian Eno! :devil:

I voted 9/10.

 

I really like the tekst and the music. I'm just disappointed about the singing. Why ruin a good voice?

I'm not voting now, it has to grow on me first.

I like the live version way better!

Ill listen to it more times

 

 

But hugely dissapointed about what they did to Chris Martin´s voice

 

Live version > this version

 

my thoughts, it kind hurts :\ :disappointed:

Now i know why ETIAW and MM (studio version - live was better) didn't made for LP5 :). 7/10. My hopes for MTM to be my 10of10 - rising :).

I actually love his voice, it's like there are 2 persons singing Chris and Jonny or Chris and Will.

I would have rated it a 10 but Chris' voice...:\

Good song if not a distorted voice. But it could be actually a b-side, the beginning and end suggest not a good mixing.

Live: 11/10

 

Studio: ... :cry:

Now i know why ETIAW and MM (studio version - live was better) didn't made for LP5 :). 7/10. My hopes for MTM to be my 10of10 - rising :).

 

Sadly I think MTM would have also "computer" voice, maybe because Chris thinks computer = technical = astronomy = solar system / space / stars. Would be lame if true.

The filtered vocals suit the song perfectly for me. The drums, bass line and crashing guitar crunch just ROCK! 9/10 because the lingering guitar echo from the live version is sadly omitted.

Its clearly Will singing with Chris!

Guess who has it on repeat on her iPod as we speak?

ME!

:dazzled:

10/10. My favorite Coldplay song ever, and I REALLY LOVE the distorty-ness. Makes the song even more epic, IMO. Also, I swear to Moffat, Will and Chris duet very clearly at points in this....

The filtered vocals suit the song perfectly for me. The drums, bass line and crashing guitar crunch just ROCK! 9/10 because the lingering guitar echo from the live version is sadly omitted.

 

So true

Live: 9/10

Studio: 5.5/10

 

What a disappointment this, they ruined Chris amazing voice and Jonny's guitar skills a bit. I need to listen more and more to get used to it, if I ever will be. I think I will listen the Live version more, which I already did a lot the past weeks.

-sorry, double post-

I like the fact that it's, like they say, overproduced. It fits the era, and they're clearly doing something different, something new.

 

And this definitely proves to me that the new era is NOT mainstream music. Whether you like the song or not, you just definitely don't usually hear stuff like this on radio.

live: 10/10

 

Studio: Don't get me started!