X&Y

Mylo Xyloto

Mylo Xyloto

Mylo Xyloto

 

No, everyone!! MX deserves to be at least in the top 5 when including the EPs!

Mylo Xyloto it is.

I think the average early-EP song is definitely better than the average MX song. But go on voting ! Let's see who wins that round. A first showdown between Oldplay and Newplay fans ;)

I think the average early-EP song is definitely better than the average MX song.

 

Understatement of the century.

I think the average early-EP song is definitely better than the average MX song. But go on voting ! Let's see who wins that round. A first showdown between Oldplay and Newplay fans ;)

 

The ep's are better than mx or gs, i think.

I vote for MX, though I must admit that I did enjoy the album, despite its weaker songs, pop influences, and overproduction. Such a shame that something with Eno's name on it could have such messy and cluttered mixes. :(

I vote for MX, though I must admit that I did enjoy the album, despite its weaker songs, pop influences, and overproduction. Such a shame that something with Eno's name on it could have such messy and cluttered mixes. :(

 

It's because eno wasn't a producer on MX he was more of a consultant on the album.

Round 2 is over !

 

Mylo Xyloto 6

Safety 4

Brothers and Sisters 2

X&Y 1

 

Mylo Xyloto has gone where they don't know its name. Oldplayers may secretly (or not-so-secretly) rejoice.

 

The contestants for round 3 are:

 

Safety

Brothers and Sisters

The Blue Room

Parachutes

A Rush Of Blood To The Head

X&Y

Viva La Vida Or Death And All His Friends

Prospekt's March

 

It may get more interesting now since there seems to generally be an unspoken consensus that GS and MX are not among Coldplay's best, so now it's gonna be a lot more difficult to decide !

 

I vote for the Blue Room, because all its songs except See you soon feature on other records so I never quite got warm with that particular record.

Brothers and sisters

Safety

Brothers and Sisters

Safety

Safety

Safety

X&Y

Safety

Don't be too harsh on The Blue Room, It's got the ambient, haunting version of Don't Panic and See You Soon!

 

I vote Safety

You can just add a vote for X&Y from me each round until it goes out.

 

So...X&Y

You can just add a vote for X&Y from me each round until it goes out.

 

So...X&Y

 

No offence, but I genuinely hope X&Y will make it into the top 3 ! :)

Safety 6

 

Brothers and Sisters 2

 

X&Y 2

 

The Blue Room 1

 

Sadly, Safety has passed what may be its one last chance of saving its innocence.

Round 3 is on ! With these contestants:

 

Brothers and Sisters

The Blue Room

Parachutes

A Rush Of Blood To The Head

X&Y

Viva La Vida Or Death And All His Friends

Prospekt's March

 

I still vote for The Blue Room

Brothers and sisters

Brothers and Sisters