The initial waltz at the start is beautiful, but has anyone noticed it then transitions into 5/4 time signature once the poem + accompanying piano actually starts... It feels so natural that you don't even consciously notice it until you start counting the beat!

Anyone else think the piano interlude was once "Radio Dial - Waltz in B Minor"?

 

You're not far off, it might actually be that, considering we hear a radio tune, then the piano piece is in b-minor. It's actually played by Khatia Buniatishvili.

Beautiful interlude.

I love how it transitions right into Army of One too

I love how it transitions right into Army of One too

 

I love how Army of One transitions into....ok no I´ll stop here. I can already feel the tomatoes being thrown my way *lol*

I love how Army of One transitions into....ok no I´ll stop here. I can already feel the tomatoes being thrown my way *lol*

 

True that XD Love the song you're referring to BTW

Elvis

Buddy Holly

The Beach Boys

Bob Dylan

Chuck Berry

 

:P

 

Actually The Beach Boys when they were led by Brian Wilson in the late 60s was inspired by The Beatles and vise versa. He made Pet Sounds they wrote Sgt Peppers then he tried to make SMiLE which due to numerous factors drove him to insanity. Its very sad considering he was such a taleted person. Watch Love&Mercy for more on him great semi-biopic :)

This track oddly reminds me of the movie The Great Gatsby. It just has that feel to it...

This track truly moves me every time, both the words but also the melody.

 

And I love The Great Gatsby, though such a sad ending.

I don't knoe if this has been mentioned or not but anyme remember the crisis liverpool gig post viva era.. anways i remember at the end of trouble he played around on the piano and it was kaleidoscope 6 years after

Here's the video

 

I don't knoe if this has been mentioned or not but anyme remember the crisis liverpool gig post viva era.. anways i remember at the end of trouble he played around on the piano and it was kaleidoscope 6 years after

Here's the video

 

Hum, it doesn't really sound like Kaleidoscope to me. I mean, it is similar but I don't think it's the same.

I might be wrong, though.

It definitely sounds similar to the melody in Kaleidoscope, but not exactly the same. Who knows, it might indeed be the root of Kaleidoscope :D

Omgosh! This is definitely Kaleidoscope. It has to be! It sounds so much like it. ("We'll should rehearse that" he says at the end. Sounds like we have uncovered a conspiracy)

It doesn't sound like Kaleidoscope to me...to my ears the chords sound completely different but the tempo and the change of chords as well as mood are similar/reminiscent of it. My money are on a no for this being the origin of Kaleidoscope, but nice find :D

The part i really hear is just the beginning of kaleidoscope before the poem starts where it sounds like it's being played through a radio

WOW. That sounds almost exactly like Kaleidoscope! Just higher, Especially the beginning... if you can't play 4:11 on and then play the beginning of Kaleidoscope without noticing only that difference I mentioned, I don't know what to tell you... I guarantee this was Kaleidoscope's roots. "We'll should rehearse that" too. They were obviously planning to do something with it. And now look, a full 6 years later, we have the final version of this sudden spark of creativity... (I don't know if they came up with it before or improvised btw... I'm just tsaying that'd be cool if he had a sudden improvisation thought and he played that). One thing though, I don't know why it had to be a full 6 years later. I do think I remember something about it being planned for release in the Mylo era, but I'm not too sure, because someone made a connection to it and a song title that never saw the light of day from back then (?) but maybe it just wasn't ready yet... probably a part of the acoustic album which got trashed, then skipped GS (although this would have fit on there too), but finally found it's home in AHFOD. The similarities tho... you can't deny that Kaliedoscope was at least in part inspired by this little improvisation :)

I've been listening to kaleidoscope and I can help but starting to imagine I'm listening to the radio. I guess that's why the band has a lot of radios on the stage.

I don't like Kaleidoscope, it's the only song I skip everytime.

I've recently started enjoying this track. I don't skip it anymore now :)

At first I thought the poem was about being friendly to everybody or something like that, but now that I've listened to it with open ears I see it has more to do with fully embracing any experience and/or emotion that comes your way - "welcome and entertain them all." I like this concept. :thumbsup:

Hate to destroy the excitement here, but the piano at the beginning of Kaleidoscope, and maybe throughout the song, is sampled from Khatia Buniatishvilli--see video. Chris had mentioned really liking Chopin during the recording of AHFOD, so I bet he was listening to Khatia's amazing renditions and wanted to use it for the track.

 

I am not a classical music expert, but maybe what he was playing at the end of Trouble is a known classical piano song? Just my first thought... Regardless, it is absolutely lovely and makes me mad. Why? Because I want an entire Coldplay album where there is just Postcards style piano tracks with the rest of the band adding awesome atmospherics. Tis my dream. Even if it was a Chris solo album....*braces for reactions*

 

Hate to destroy the excitement here, but the piano at the beginning of Kaleidoscope, and maybe throughout the song, is sampled from Khatia Buniatishvilli--see video. Chris had mentioned really liking Chopin during the recording of AHFOD, so I bet he was listening to Khatia's amazing renditions and wanted to use it for the track.

 

I am not a classical music expert, but maybe what he was playing at the end of Trouble is a known classical piano song? Just my first thought... Regardless, it is absolutely lovely and makes me mad. Why? Because I want an entire Coldplay album where there is just Postcards style piano tracks with the rest of the band adding awesome atmospherics. Tis my dream. Even if it was a Chris solo album....*braces for reactions*

 

I'm sitting here wondering what it is in the video you find that matches the beginning piano portion of Kaleidoscope. I took the time to listen to that piece. It is very complicated compared to Kaleidoscope. They seem to match key (if you get my music lingo) but only in a few places. And my ear tells me they're not the same in those places. Other than that Katia's piece is all over the place in terms of key changes. Another thing you may notice is that Kaleidoscope is in 3/4 time while this piece is in 4/4. So I see no similarities here :)

I think it's actually kind of similar to Kaleidoscope, but still they have sampled it from Khatia Buniatishvili. However, I think this ending reminds almost the same much of Jonny's solo in Another's Arms ... A new conspiracy theory haha!

Did anyone find the piece it was sampled from?

 

Or maybe it wasn't sampled, but an original piece.

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=1053959211323600

Mobile Link: https://www.facebook.com/khatia.buniatishvili/posts/1053959211323600

The voiceover is the best part of it for me! Absolutely love this interlude so much and I don't even know why

 

It's by far my favourite song on the album. The melody is so peaceful, and the message in the poem is magical. It gives me so much comfort and I'm so thankful for it.