December 13, 201015 yr I think some pages ago howyousawtheworld already made points about JB's guitar work on album being simplified solely to accompany the music in the best way possible, and nobody argued with that (I mean Mogwai are shit without mega guitar solos LUL) but we also discussed whether he even has the talent to play solos or anything which is difficult technically. You can be a shit guitarist but be great creatively no doubt, but the original point was whether he has the ability to play difficult music.
December 13, 201015 yr I think some pages ago howyousawtheworld already made points about JB's guitar work on album being simplified solely to accompany the music in the best way possible, and nobody argued with that (I mean Mogwai are shit without mega guitar solos LUL) but we also discussed whether he even has the talent to play solos or anything which is difficult technically. You can be a shit guitarist but be great creatively no doubt, but the original point was whether he has the ability to play difficult music. I am not a musician and can't really estimate solos for being difficult or not. But maybe more skilled people can tell if Bigger Stronger counts for decent guitar playing?
December 13, 201015 yr You can be a shit guitarist but be great creatively no doubt, but the original point was whether he has the ability to play difficult music. I've come to the opinion that most band musicians, if given a sheet of music, could not play it. I think most of them play by ear, and if that's what you mean I'm not sure, maybe. I'm pretty much certain that if you gave Jonny Buckland a sheet of concert guitar music he'd be lost though. :P Band geeks <3 :lips:
December 13, 201015 yr Quite alot of guitarists can read music, I personally prefer Sheet Music to tabs but that may have to do with me starting off on the piano:laugh3:.
December 13, 201015 yr I am not a musician and can't really estimate solos for being difficult or not. But maybe more skilled people can tell if Bigger Stronger counts for decent guitar playing? I'm listening to it, certainly a lot more active, but if you mean the tremolo (trembling effect on the guitar) that's a straightforward technique. I'm not going to bother getting sheet music and learning it, but I doubt I'd be stumped. I suppose it doesn't sound much more difficult then a lot of Pink Floyd songs (Just using that example because it was quite Floydy) but the point is that Pink Floyd did have some songs that were pretty tricky to play.
December 13, 201015 yr Quite alot of guitarists can read music, I personally prefer Sheet Music to tabs but that may have to do with me starting off on the piano:laugh3:. Well, I don't play guitar, I don't know the difference between tabs and sheet music. :P Everything's in sheet music for me. :lol:
December 13, 201015 yr Well, I don't play guitar, I don't know the difference between tabs and sheet music. :P Everything's in sheet music for me. :lol: no 100% guitar expert here, but for the few i learnt is: tabs have just the signs/info of strings or chords you have to use on a song sheet music, you ought to know how is, you know the pentagram thing, with music symbols which give the lenght of the notes. am i rite?
December 13, 201015 yr no 100% guitar expert here, but for the few i learnt is: tabs have just the strings or chords you have to use on a song sheet music, you ought to know how is, you know the pentagram thing, with music symbols which give the lenght of the notes. Oh, so tabs don't have rhythm or anything?
December 13, 201015 yr Oh, so tabs don't have rhythm or anything? for what i've seen, not... that or i'm total ignorant, i find tabs harder to understand than a sheet music, really due to lack of rhythm (notes lenght) signs. i could be wrong. please a proper guitarist do correct my mistake.
December 13, 201015 yr No you're right, tabs just indicate which string to pluck and which fret your fingers should be on pretty much, obviously there's slightly more to it but I generally prefer Sheet Music if I have a choice.
December 13, 201015 yr Basically you can play sheet music without having to hear the song, tabs you totally rely on hearing it.
December 14, 201015 yr According to the person who did this video, these are Jonny's most remarkable musical moments: [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsjRkNinLdU]YouTube - Coldplay - Jonny Buckland Guitar HD Quality[/ame] And according to this person, these are the best solos: [ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z055gQUgHgQ]YouTube - Coldplay's Best Guitar Solos[/ame] In my opinion, the only thing I actually like is how he played in AROBTTH 2003. The rest of his work isn't hard to try on guitar.
December 14, 201015 yr I like it, but if someone said I could never listen to it again, I wouldn't care.
December 14, 201015 yr So in conclusion while JB's guitar work may not be technically challenging it does serve it's sole purpose well - atmosphere. That is all!
December 14, 201015 yr Forgettable lyrics and boring instrumentals. Only redeemable quality is the piano. I'm afraid Coldplay will never again come close to what it was pre-2007.
December 14, 201015 yr So in conclusion while JB's guitar work may not be technically challenging it does serve it's sole purpose well - atmosphere. That is all! Derp.
Create an account or sign in to comment