Welcome to Coldplaying!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

SignUp Now!

Critic ratings.

getithom

Baby blue.
Honorary Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
May 11, 2009
Messages
3,973
yeah! and still ranking mylo over both x&y and GS? i think we can safely say good bye to any grammys next year. critically, this has had a worse acceptance than mylo.
And that honestly surprises me. For a while, it seemed like it'd be going the other direction.
 

Corkus

Pretentious Tool
Coldplayer
Joined
Nov 20, 2008
Messages
4,461
LOL, Pitchfork called Sky Full of Stars the highlight. They didn't get their Coldplay fan writer to review it, though.
 

gai

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Nov 10, 2011
Messages
3,585
And that honestly surprises me. For a while, it seemed like it'd be going the other direction.
me too. the biggest drawback for me was the lyrical limitations (to put it one way). but don't think it deserves the trashing that it's getting. coldplay are doomed if they do and doomed if they don't anyway.
anyway, from the band's viewpoint, i don't think this is an album that may be weighed the same as the previous ones as it is more of a personal affair.

p.s. really didn't this reviewer hear oceans?? to me that's one of the best accoustic-y tracks they have ever done.
 

Mackplay

Coldslay
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 18, 2009
Messages
2,219
The Pitchfork review is so ridiculous that it made me laugh.

They hated Midnight and its amazing video. They hated True Love as well. How is this even possible? This shows the guy just hates Coldplay and will never like any of their stuffs.
They didn't even mention Oceans. They also didn't mention Always In My Head. 2 of the album highlights!!
The reviewer obviously wanted a grandiose album like MX with big anthems, that's why he was so harsh.
Coldplay consciously decided to make a stripped down album so hating the album because it's not full of anthems is actually a compliment.
 

teernabh5

Strawberry Swinger
Coldplayer
Joined
Sep 21, 2011
Messages
1,178
I think the excessive simplicity of the lyrics is pissing people off. Chris does come up with good lyrics like Viva and even many of the lyrics of Mylo. Maybe, now that he has more free time he can come with an album with more complex lyrics. The melody need not be worried about.
 

brotherbeck

New Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 4, 2014
Messages
3
I can't lie, The Quietus review made me laugh really hard even though I don't agree with what the writer is saying about either the album or the band. The review of GS on Drowned in Sound though pretty much sums up exactly how I feel about the album, though I am obviously a bigger fan of the band in general than the writer is.

This album, and I guess people's reactions to Coldplay as a band in general, remind me a lot of a movie I just watched - The Secret Life of Walter Mitty. It's a movie that was absolutely torn to shreds by the press and reviewers. From the way they mercilessly tore it and Ben Stiller apart I would have thought it was one of the worst movies ever made. I watched it and actually enjoyed it a lot. It's a well made sincere little movie - little in the sense of the story it tells, not little when it comes to budget and special effects - that just tells a story about a guy learning a life lesson. You could tell the people making it put some real thought into it, something that cannot be said for many of the movies churned out by the modern film
industry. Is it a modern cinematic masterpiece? No. Can you tell Ben Stiller might have been trying just a little bit too hard for some serious critical acclaim / awards recognition? Absolutely, but it's still a really good movie. It also struck me as earnest and sincere - two things a lot of people love to mock as uncool.

Anyone who makes art and releases it is putting themselves and their work out there. Other people are going to judge it and you. When you've already been very commercially and critically successful, people are twice as likely to be ready to try to take you down, it's just human nature. People can be petty and jealous. I think it takes guts to put something out there and not hide behind irony or not taking yourself too seriously - especially when tackling something so personal as the dissolution of a marriage in such a straight forward manner.

Plus, these guys are hard workers. I do think a song like ASFOS was put on the album strictly to be a big radio hit and drive up sales - but a lot of other bands, either through lack of talent or laziness, would just do that and surround that song and maybe one other good one with a bunch of forgettable filler. I think their relationship to ASFOS is one of grudging appeasement of the record company suits, like "yeah alright, we'll put one like that on there for you" - where other band's one big radio hit is really the best that they can do in a lot of cases.
 

likeafire

Scientist
Coldplayer
Joined
Nov 10, 2008
Messages
275
Its the worst rated coldplay album ever. I cant see any grammy awards or other awards for the album as they go on what critics say and how its accepted.

Ive been a long enough coldplay fan to know theyll never be accepted by the critics. They could write a song like stairway to heaven and theyd still think its rubbish.

I cant see why its getting so many bad reviews as its actually a really good album but oh well
 

MrMilanista

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
153
I've never really understood how they rate the albums, I mean El Camino had much better score than Viva la Vida (!) and Mylo Xyloto even though the only real good song was Lonely Boy. Viva la Vida is a much better album with much better and consistent songs. Fucked up world, really
 

Revolverwin

Strawberry Swing
Coldplayer
Joined
Jul 13, 2011
Messages
906
The major critics (NME, Entertainment weekly, Rolling Stone, Spin) gave GS a pretty nice score. Pitchfork is an exception of course:D
 

matti

Coldplayer
Coldplayer
Joined
Feb 9, 2009
Messages
91
Pitchfork has always been a supporter of Coldplay's grandiose, experimental and bombastic albums than the smaller and quieter ones (well except X&Y). Talking into account their ratings for VLVDAAHF and MX (6-7 rating). Ghost Stories is no exception to this mindset.
 

felinegurl

♡ 5.5.14 ♡
Coldplayer
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
221
A review by Australia's harshest music reviewer:

Oh fuck sake.... :rolleyes:

So basically, this guy just gets paid to insult musicians? Because I've just looked him up and I haven't seen one review with more than 1 star. He gave Robin Thicke's album no stars (literally......it said 'no stars'. I don't disagree with that rating, but still, lol). At least he's creative with his insults I guess
 
Top